Fitting Bianchi did I get it wrong!?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Noahs_arc

Regular
Well there you go!, cycling comes in to my life. For may years I have dismissed going out on a road bike for two main reasons 1) when I was a kid my father had an affair and took 'my' spanking new road bike (Raleigh of course) and gave it to his 'bit of stuff's' son! - yeah imagine that... well upset I was. He came back to the family but never replaced the bike!. He wasn't the spiteful type, just liked a bit of skirt :-) 2) I bought a mountain bike early 90's and hated every stroke/pedal on the road. Effort vs Return not good, so it was relegated to the back of the shed for simple rides down the river bank! I even bought a second MT bike as I didn't believe how bad the first one was. Still hated it.

So years passed with tennis, football and jogging buggering up my knee I was coaxed, by a mate, to look at road bikes. "Man he said you'll love it and you'll shed the pounds off" ...lose pounds?!!! that sounds good. So I jumped in the deep end and off I popped to Evans London to simply buy a good bike!. Yeah Italian I thought, bit of bling but not tooooo much. Wilier that's the one for me so the very helpful assistant in Evans pulled out a Trestina 55 cm - 'jump on that' he said. This guy knew alot about fitting and had his own fitting business. Narh my shoulders felt over the handlebars 'that's too small he said they do come up small'. Now I'm 15 1/2st - 5' 8" - about a 30 inside leg, 'I think the next size up will be too big for you'. 'How about this baby' >pointing to a Bianchi C2C Nirone 57 cm >celeste< "WHAT that -Do you think I'm a girl?" Yeah it's a matter of taste. Anyway for a laugh i jumped on it. Hey this doesn't feel too bad. Ping Ping stick it on the credit card..

Off I trot on my first three rides. Ah freedom, bliss, no kids, no wife for 2 to 3 hours. Effort vs Rewards = massive. BUT then the pins and needles set in, quick phone call back to my mate at the shop. Result of the conversation = I buy a shorter stem 150 down to 100. That should do it. Erh NO! (I'll live with it) Then the big one! after consistent riding, I start to get pains right across the top left hand side of my chest just above the heart and below the collar bone. Eeek heart issues? Hmm not sure, so I have an ECG results fine, but blood pressure on the high side 150/100. Move on; as I work in the NHS I had access to a Cardiologist and I mentioned this to her, just after I told her how attractive she looked ;-) she said "hmmm that's too high for angina she prodded me and said that looks like a muscular complaint, however get yourself thoroughly checked out. Basically I can ride for 3 hours, feel great, but I need to massage the area above the heart to ease the dull pain off. Then I'm fine. Back on the bike 2 / 3 days after 30 miles no problems. massage again. During the day niggles.

What the hell could this be? So one thought was that perhaps the bike is too big for me. I have been to a fitting service (specialist in triathletes - skinny bastards) and took the bike, they never mentioned that the bike was too big for me - we fiddled around with the seat up/down front/back.... and foot position. Ping £75 cheers!

So getting down to the real questions. 1) Has any one experienced this type of pain and 2) would a 57cm Bianchi be suitable for my build? 3) is there a difference between sizes/feel on these types of bikes. I don't get the process of erh try this bike and getting a proper fitting surely you'd need to take a dozen bikes to the fitting service. Dont think Evans would approve of that agreement. What do you think!?
 

RoyPSB

Über Member
Well there you go!, cycling comes in to my life. For may years I have dismissed going out on a road bike for two main reasons 1) when I was a kid my father had an affair and took 'my' spanking new road bike (Raleigh of course) and gave it to his 'bit of stuff's' son! - yeah imagine that... well upset I was. He came back to the family but never replaced the bike!. He wasn't the spiteful type, just liked a bit of skirt :-) 2) I bought a mountain bike early 90's and hated every stroke/pedal on the road. Effort vs Return not good, so it was relegated to the back of the shed for simple rides down the river bank! I even bought a second MT bike as I didn't believe how bad the first one was. Still hated it.

So years passed with tennis, football and jogging buggering up my knee I was coaxed, by a mate, to look at road bikes. "Man he said you'll love it and you'll shed the pounds off" ...lose pounds?!!! that sounds good. So I jumped in the deep end and off I popped to Evans London to simply buy a good bike!. Yeah Italian I thought, bit of bling but not tooooo much. Wilier that's the one for me so the very helpful assistant in Evans pulled out a Trestina 55 cm - 'jump on that' he said. This guy knew alot about fitting and had his own fitting business. Narh my shoulders felt over the handlebars 'that's too small he said they do come up small'. Now I'm 15 1/2st - 5' 8" - about a 30 inside leg, 'I think the next size up will be too big for you'. 'How about this baby' >pointing to a Bianchi C2C Nirone 57 cm >celeste< "WHAT that -Do you think I'm a girl?" Yeah it's a matter of taste. Anyway for a laugh i jumped on it. Hey this doesn't feel too bad. Ping Ping stick it on the credit card..

Off I trot on my first three rides. Ah freedom, bliss, no kids, no wife for 2 to 3 hours. Effort vs Rewards = massive. BUT then the pins and needles set in, quick phone call back to my mate at the shop. Result of the conversation = I buy a shorter stem 150 down to 100. That should do it. Erh NO! (I'll live with it) Then the big one! after consistent riding, I start to get pains right across the top left hand side of my chest just above the heart and below the collar bone. Eeek heart issues? Hmm not sure, so I have an ECG results fine, but blood pressure on the high side 150/100. Move on; as I work in the NHS I had access to a Cardiologist and I mentioned this to her, just after I told her how attractive she looked ;-) she said "hmmm that's too high for angina she prodded me and said that looks like a muscular complaint, however get yourself thoroughly checked out. Basically I can ride for 3 hours, feel great, but I need to massage the area above the heart to ease the dull pain off. Then I'm fine. Back on the bike 2 / 3 days after 30 miles no problems. massage again. During the day niggles.

What the hell could this be? So one thought was that perhaps the bike is too big for me. I have been to a fitting service (specialist in triathletes - skinny bastards) and took the bike, they never mentioned that the bike was too big for me - we fiddled around with the seat up/down front/back.... and foot position. Ping £75 cheers!

So getting down to the real questions. 1) Has any one experienced this type of pain and 2) would a 57cm Bianchi be suitable for my build? 3) is there a difference between sizes/feel on these types of bikes. I don't get the process of erh try this bike and getting a proper fitting surely you'd need to take a dozen bikes to the fitting service. Dont think Evans would approve of that agreement. What do you think!?

I'm 5'8 and I would think a 57 Bianchi would be too big. 55 would probably be the right size - but I'm no expert.

Gorgeous bike though. Hope you get the problem fixed.
 

Alembicbassman

Confused.com
Frame mfrs measure differently. My Raleigh U6 is badged as a 58cm, but centre to top is 56cm. My Giant Defy is 55.5cm (Large in Giants catalogue) I'm 6ft 1 inch 33 inch inside leg. A 57cm does sound a bit big for 5ft 8 inch. You sure the stem was 150mm? I had a 130mm on my Raleigh which was long, dropped it to a 110mm which was better for me.
 

snailracer

Über Member
The end goal of "fitting" is to establish the relative positions of saddle, pedals and bars i.e. your contact points with the bike. It should be possible to transfer this fit to all but the most grossly-incorrect frame sizes, although you might need a different stem, saddle clamp, etc. if there is not enough adjustment in the original components.
The only thing you can't really adjust is the clearance between your crotch and top tube.
 

Herzog

Swinglish Mountain Goat
I'm 6 foot exaxtly and my Bianchi Sempre is a 57. I could go a size smaller, so I guess a 57 is on the large side for someone who is 5' 8".
 

VamP

Banned
Location
Cambs
6ft 1'' and 59cm C2C

no comfort issues at all
 

yello

Guest
What snailracer says. There's a bit of leeway on frame sizing; one can adjust saddle position and stem length etc. But, I have to say, on the face of it that does sound a frame size too far - I would have expected you to be on a smaller frame.
 

fossyant

Ride It Like You Stole It!
Location
South Manchester
I'm 5"9 and ride 56cm old school road bikes, or 52/54 compacts (depending upon top tube = 54 top tube is ideal).

I have a longer torso. 57 sounds way to big.

Can you post a pic of the bike as is set up.
 

EYE-TYE-MAD

New Member
Firstly, it's important to understand just how Bianchi & most other manufacturers size their frames, i.e. virtually. Many moons ago when all frames had a straight top tube it was simply a matter of measuring from the centre of the bottom bracket to the centre, or top of the seat tube to determine frame size & hence rider height compatibility. The Bianchi size given, 57cm, doesn't actually exist, it's the size the frame would have been had the top tube been straight. So, to the question of whether a 57cm Bianchi is too big for someone of 5' 8" with an inside leg of 30". Well unfortunately, there is yet another factor to consider, top tube length. I myself own three Bianchi's, a Nirone, an XL EV2 & a 928 SL. I am roughly your height give or take. All three of my Bianchis have an actual, not virtual, seat tube length of 48cm; the Nirone's top tube is 53cm, the EV2's is 54cm & the 928's is 55cm. In my opinion, & I must stress it is only my opinion as size is to a certain degree subjective, a Bianchi 57cm frame would be a bit of a stretch for someone of your height. I would have said that a 57cm Bianchi would not be suitable for anyone under a height of 5' 9".
 
Might be a stupid, obvious question but...

When you go out for three hours, are you wearing a backpack? If so, give it a go without, once. Make sure someone is reachable on a phone to rescue you if you get a puncture and can't take kit with you.

You never know, it might be a kit issue...
 

IT_Dummy

New Member
Go for a treadmill test. I got my second wind on mine. If everthing is fine. The pain is stress
My pains took 3 years to go away. Its a slow process.
I use to rush to the A&E they threw me out within seconds after a ECG
The Cardioligist know their stuff
 

cyberknight

As long as I breathe, I attack.
I'm 5"9 and ride 56cm old school road bikes, or 52/54 compacts (depending upon top tube = 54 top tube is ideal).

I have a longer torso. 57 sounds way to big.

Can you post a pic of the bike as is set up.
Sounds spot on to me fossy , the bike does sound to big but its hard to tell without piccies of the OP on the bike , i am 5 foot 7 " with a 30.5 inside leg and i ride 52/54 cm bikes with a 54 cm top tube .
 
Top Bottom