Crankarm said:
Lent like New Year's Resolutions - doomed to failure. Mind I always say I'll give up smoking. Haven't broken this resolution.
Why can't Lent be like Ramadan then you can at least eat during the hours of darkness - am I right?
Lent - God stuff - all about control and making you feel bad or a sinner as no one can realistically keep to it.
No, fasting is nothing to do with guilt.
Fasting is to do with denial, yes, but it's also to do with spirituality. In all religions, the great thinkers have done their "best thinking" while fasting. We're told Christ did his in the wilderness for 40 days, which is the inspiration for Lent. Mohammed (PBUH) did much the same, hence Ramadan.
Buddha sat under a tree for a long time, and came up with some pretty startling sense (ie that the best way to stop feeling unhappy because you haven't got something is to stop wanting it....something we could all learn from I reckon!)
Nowadays however periods of fasting are linked with charitable giving. Lent suggests we give something up and increase charitable giving. Muslims give in order to feed the poor during Ramadan. Both Christians and Muslims that I know believe that by fasting you enter into a more spritual, deeper thinking state, and use the time of fasting to reflect and study.
You may not be a religious man, but if you deliberately misinterpret others' beliefs, you hardly respect the good they are doing do you?