ukdodger said:
Since they look largly the same I wonder where the price goes.
The price goes on materials and design. Just like on bikes, and just like on bikes it obeys the law of diminishing returns.
For my two pennnorth:
- First of all avoid any single skin tents as you WILL suffer from condensation in UK conditions.
- Consider what sort of use you will put the tent to. Will you be camping exclusively on lowland campsites or are you hoping to go wild camping in winter on Scottish mountains? The latter will obviously require a more robust tent - possibly with a different design (eg semi geodesic tents are often self supporting and can be weighed down by boulders etc if necessary whereas tunnel tents usually need to be well pitched as their strength comes from the guys)
- Look how close the flysheet is to the ground when the tent is pitched. The closer it is then the tent should shed high winds well, but it may suffer more from condenstaion as you need to get air in between the fly and inner to combat that (flysheets have vents for this reason but they do not always work brilliantly)
- Always go for a tent that has alloy (preferably Easton alloy) poles as they are far stronger than cheap fibreglass ones
- For year round use a two layer door that can be zipped back to just an anti midge net in summer but zipped to for winter can work well.
- Very light tents are often light at the expense of thick fabrics - especiually the groundsheet. Thin groundsheets are more prone to puncture, and it is always a good idea to buy or make a groundsheet protector in any case.
- How tall are you? You may find yourself stuck in a tent for some time and if you are over six foot then lots of tents will only allow you to sit hunched up and you will not have much room to sleep full length.
- Get a tent with a decent sized porch. That way you have room for wet gear and can (carefully) brew up under the porch if it is hammering down.
- Tunnel tents tent to be lighter and give more available space that the equivalent sized geodesic.
An earlier question asked about self inflating mats. They work very well, even the cheap thin models. They work by them inflating themselves when you unscrew the valve. You can add a couple of puffs to make sure you get a good fill. You then expel the air in the morning, seal the valve and roll it up.