Ahhhh!!!! Help me choose!!! The phones in the poll are all good, but I can't decide which to go for!!
I think the problem with your poll is anyone with the HTC Desire will vote for it, similar with the iPhone etc. People do get a bit fanatical about this. I think age has an influence as well. I'm mid 50s and wanted the following from a phone, good sync with Outlook, easy use, large buttons (had a Blackberry for a week, useless because the buttons are tiny), web access, e-mail, good calendar and contacts. I also lusted after GPS to use on my bike. If you want these features on a simple to use phone then iPhone is for you - though the GPS is pointless on the bike as it only lasts 2-3 hours!!
I have found one or two useful apps but most seem pretty irrelevant to my life so I'm not sure all that type of stuff is very relevant. Of course this depends entirely on how electronic one's life is. It's been easy to load stuff on Facebook on the rare occassion I want to do this. The IP Board app for reading this board and another favourite of mine is great. The iPhone camera is OK for my limited ability and if I need to take good pictures I still find a real camera works well.
All in all the iPhone is a very good phone, quick, simple to use and has a nice feel about it. Battery life is not the big issue people make out. I use the iPod function about 2 hours per day, have Bluetooth on all the time, make all my business and personal calls, regularly update e-mail and read the web and I have yet to drain the battery to the point it creates a problem. I charge it when necessary and it hasn't been a big deal. I'm not evangelical about my phone the way some folk can be. The iPhone works, everytime, end of story.
I've never even seen the HTC Desire so I wouldn't join the comprison discussion.