arallsopp
Post of The Year 2009 winner
- Location
- Bromley, Kent
it still seems to smack of using less energy to transport a given mass a given distance which makes me uncomfortable!!!
Its not less energy. Its just using more of the energy to propel the bikes.
Consider the following scenario.
I'm out with Mikey on the 'bent. Along for the ride is our mate Ian on an upright. We've all carefully selected diets, components and steeds to ensure we have identical mass. We're spaced out, rolling down a hill, all using the same amount of gravity, nobody pedalling.
Ian is up front. As a product of his speed, he's losing energy to a high pressure "wall" of air that's forming in front of him. He's also losing energy to a low pressure "hole" that's being dragged behind him. Sleeves ripple. Leaves whip up in his wake.
I'm 50ft back. Due to my recumbent bike, my high pressure wall is much smaller (as I present a smaller frontal area). I'm dragging a low pressure hole behind me, but again, its smaller than Ian's. Leaves shift a little in my wake. Sleeves lay flat.
Result: I catch up. Same mass. Same distance. Same gravity. More speed. Less of my energy is being used to lift leaves and make buffeting noises on my arms.
Now let's add Mikey. He's on a recumbent with a tailbox. He has the same high pressure wall in front, but an even smaller low pressure hole behind him, as the tailbox gives him a nice aerodynamic shape at the back. Leaves glance upwards, and ignore him.
Result: He catches me. Same mass. Same distance. Same gravity. More speed.
As I catch up with Ian, I start to fit into the low pressure hole he's creating. Now I'm acting as a tailbox for his bike. Leaves lose interest. He starts to roll faster. Ian is still losing a fair amount of energy on the high pressure wall in front, but everything behind is getting tidier.
Now I roll alongside him. The tailbox effect drops and he slows down a little. I still present a smaller frontal area to the wind, so drift past and slot in front. Unfortunately for Ian, he's a fair whack higher than the low pressure hole I'm presenting, so gets almost no benefit.
In this scenario, its easier for him if I'm wheelsucking than leading.
Of course, it all becomes irrelevant when Gaz speeds past playing Mr Slippy with the tuck, and Mikey and I break formation to go chase him