New commuting bike - please help

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Yimkin

New Member
Hi all,

New to the forums, and I'm sure (well I know) this is an oft asked question, but everyones situation is different as you know!

My company is introducing the cycle to work scheme, and I'm looking to get a bike under it for occasional commuting to work.

The commute is a round trip of 28 miles, in the western lake district (Cockermouth to Whitehaven), so fairly hilly. Of the 14 mile (1 way) trip, at a guess it would be about 30 to 40% surfaced cycle path, around 30% A road (single carriageway) and 30% town A road.

I used to commute by bike when I lived in Cambridge - depending where I lived it was anything from 1 mile round trip to 10 mile round trip, for which I used heavy old heaps. I have a Kona Fire Mountain (05) at the moment, and do 'occasional' 10 mile rides (50/50 on/off road). As such I realise I'll have to build up my fitness before commuting that distance. I might be built like a racing snake (5'11" and 10 stone) but I definitely wouldn't consider myself fit. I'm 38 by the way.

Questions as follows!

1) Am I being stupid even considering this?

2) How do you deal with traffic on an A road (a fast one at that)? Using a primary position is a bit of a no no in a way, although no problem with confidence in cycling outside the inner white line.

3) I'm only planning (at least to begin with) to cycle maybe twice a week in good (summer weather). I already have cycling shorts and top, but should I consider cycling shoes (I don't like SPDs by the way - tried them and fell off. A lot.).

4) The biggie. What bike? Under the cycle to work scheme I can get 58% discount. I have been looking at the Kona Dew (I like Kona's!). I'm a bit of a sad git, in the sense that looks are important to me. I realise that lightness is a priority, but if, say, a Kona Dew is 399 (around 200 under cycle to work), would I get a significant benefit spending, say 600 (around 280 under cycle to work)? For example, I like Cannondale bad boy's, but are they worth the extra cash? As I am going relatively long distance, what bikes in the, say, 400 to 600 price range have road gears?

5) A slight aside - most hybrids seem to be targeted at people cycling round town. I'm not going to be doing that, it's a relatively long distance commute across country. Any bikes targeted at that? I'm sorry to roadies out there, but I hate drop bars (I just can't get on with them and never feel stable)

Apologies for the essay, especially as a new poster, but your advice would be gratefully received!

Chris
 

gouldina

New Member
Location
London
Some of the Boardman hybrids look excellent. Basically road bikes without drops. I don't think they're in the same price range as the Kona though.
 

upsidedown

Waiting for the great leap forward
Location
The middle bit
If i liked Konas, which i do, and had a ride like that i would pull the stops out and get a Kona Sutra, lovely looking bike. All the racks and guards you could need, plus disc brakes.
 

Jezston

Über Member
Location
London
Hi there - thought I'd add my two pence as I took a similar step about six months ago.

Yimkin said:
1) Am I being stupid even considering this?
Of course not! That sounds like a lovely ride - and you should be doing it every day ;) Obviously sounds scary right now but the more you do it, the fitter you get, the more you enjoy it, the more you do it!

2) How do you deal with traffic on an A road (a fast one at that)? Using a primary position is a bit of a no no in a way, although no problem with confidence in cycling outside the inner white line.

Be plenty visible. I ride a portion of the A52 every day and it's fine, even with HGVs passing me - I have a dayglo hi-vis backpack cover with a big flashing red light on it so I won't be blending into the background.

3) I'm only planning (at least to begin with) to cycle maybe twice a week in good (summer weather). I already have cycling shorts and top, but should I consider cycling shoes (I don't like SPDs by the way - tried them and fell off. A lot.).
I refer the honourable gentleman to the comments I made earlier in this post about how often you plan to cycle! But DO get rigid soled shoes - I'm currently on some proper jogging shoes but plan to get some proper cycling shoes as things get warmer. I haven't tried clipless/SPDs yet myself and must admit I'm a little scared!
[/quote]

4) The biggie. What bike? Under the cycle to work scheme I can get 58% discount. I have been looking at the Kona Dew (I like Kona's!). I'm a bit of a sad git, in the sense that looks are important to me. I realise that lightness is a priority, but if, say, a Kona Dew is 399 (around 200 under cycle to work), would I get a significant benefit spending, say 600 (around 280 under cycle to work)? For example, I like Cannondale bad boy's, but are they worth the extra cash? As I am going relatively long distance, what bikes in the, say, 400 to 600 price range have road gears?

I got a Kona Dew Plus myself under cycle to work, and while it's a fine bicycle, now I'm a little more experienced I think I would have chosen differently if I were to make the decision now. It is a little on the heavy side, can't take mudguards due to the disc brakes, and as I'm on the road all the time having 24 gears is quite unecessary. At the time it was a toss-up between the Dew and a Specialized Sirrus - wish I'd gone for the Sirrus some times ... but I don't truly regret getting the Dew, it's serving me well ... just looking forwards to the scheme running out so I can get something REALLY fancy next time :wacko:

5) A slight aside - most hybrids seem to be targeted at people cycling round town. I'm not going to be doing that, it's a relatively long distance commute across country. Any bikes targeted at that? I'm sorry to roadies out there, but I hate drop bars (I just can't get on with them and never feel stable)

Actually in that case the Dew will probably be just the ticket!
 

J4CKO

New Member
I started on a Bad Boy 700 for my 14 (minimum) round trip commute, good bike but a firm ride, brakes are good, it did seem robust over 3000 miles, I recently got a Spec Allez Elite on the scheme and its a revelation, the lower bottom bracket I find better and its a coupel of mpf faster on average, it rides better and feels more planted.

Ergo, get a relaxed type road bike.
 
Top Bottom