LoTR gave me bum pain I will never forget or forgive. The third one in particular was simply a bad film. It had no subtlety and if I ever, ever see that **** who played Frodo give his 'meaningful' look at the camera again, I will kill large numbers of people in a public place. Tripe. Utter tripe.
However Watchmen looks like the real deal. The fact that Alain Moore has disowned it makes no odds to me - he disowns any film adaption as a matter of course. But it looks great, and they have even made the pirate sections (but separately, and it is will only be on the DVD). I don't even care if it isn't 'faithful' - films and graphic novels are different media. If it works on its own merits it is fine by me.