I think it is interesting that the request for information has been posted in this section as Touring and Expedition will bring a different set of responses to the same posts in say racing or even road rides, audax and sportives. Perhaps this was intended - elicit comment from the CTC crew rather than the BC riders. I also contend that the touring and expedition cyclist are more likely to prefer cycling on their own. Is the witness being led here?
So turning to my views on clubs. I started with a CTC club and rode with them for about 6-9 months. But it became apparent that their average speed was just too low, their desire to eat sandwiches in a bus shelter rather than the cafe we had passed 1-2 miles earlier led me to reconsider the CTC option. On moving to East Yorkshire, I joined a small road club, an excellent decision. Not only were the rides well considered, the typical cyclist were friendly and I gained some good friends from my time with them. Another move to Edinburgh and this time to the large ERC. It was less easy to make friends in a large club when the Sat ride would have over 100 riders and you were riding with new people each run. However, with perseverance, I can now claim to have some good friends at ERC.
So in conclusion, I was not impressed with my one experience of CTC - a bit strange. Road clubs for me are more successful, but there is a latent problem with a large club - more people, better range of rides and activity but harder to make friends.