Back to the drawing board, sort of.

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

mythste

Guru
Location
Manchester
So After my last thread, I thought I had a pretty good grasp of what I wanted - hardcore road bike as N+1 for my charge single speed. Was pretty set that the Giant Defy 1 offered the best value for money and that's the route I'd take.

Alas, the C2W window opens and Im expecting my voucher shortly when I decided to do that awfully silly thing of double checking my thoughts, and I all of a sudden come across this thing called Cyclocross and it looks like it might suit me down to the ground! A lot of my rides are canals, a little bit of city hopping, back paths etc and the one thing I was worried about doing on a hardcore roadie was planning my routes in such a way that I wouldnt completely B****** up my wheels.

It seems that a cyclocross will still allow me to eat up the miles on the black stuff with only a minor speed penalty but would punish me much less for taking a path less trodden.

So my question is one of value, between the Giant anyroad 1 and 2, and the Giant revolt 1 and 2.

The anyroad one is grabbing my attention the most but its at the top of my budget and I'd like a little left over for peripherals if possible. The anyroads also come with 28C tyres which I'd be happy with, the revolts come with 35c which I'd need to factor in the cost of swapping out straight away. The reason I want a Giant is that the local Giant store accepts the halfords vouchers straight up, is >5km from my house and Ive had fantastic service in there in the past. My main worry is that quality of componentry compared to the defy.

Any thoughts?
 

MikeW-71

Veteran
Location
Carlisle
Revolt.

It's not much heavier than a Defy and it runs well on road, even on the stock 35mm tyres. I fitted some 28mm 4 seasons on mine and they are a little better, but not a night-and-day difference. It can also take a rack if you want to.

The Anyroad is really heavy!

Edit: components on the Revolt 1 are Tiagra level. Bulletproof.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
mythste

mythste

Guru
Location
Manchester
Id never considered the weight difference. The anyroad does look weighty... Looking at the revolt in a new light already.

Thanks!
 

MikeW-71

Veteran
Location
Carlisle
Mine has a rack and bag on permanently now and it did well as a light tourer. Quite a versatile bike :smile: That 11-34 rear cassette got me up 15% hills with the loaded up bag seen below.

In fact the 2015 bikes have different tyres and wheels to mine. I think they've fitted better wheels to the 1 and seem to be using Schwalbe tyres instead of the Giant branded ones I got. Even the wheels on mine feel better than those on my Defy 2

14718686377_7948cc9627_c.jpg
 
OP
OP
mythste

mythste

Guru
Location
Manchester
That looks lovely! Nice to know it has the flexibility to tour - I do dream of racking up (get it?) some long haul rides.

Any other recommendations that I can get for under a grand on C2W before I order?
 
Top Bottom