Creative Photography

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Pross

Guru
Interestingly, one of the local photo club members gave a talk yesterday evening on his astrophotography.

He made the observation that (so far), it's one of the few genres that can still only be done with a camera, and not a mobile phone - I wonder how long that will continue to be the case,

The talk included a very detailed account of how he shot an image of the Milky Way against Stonehenge, published in last month's Digital Camera World.

All I've ever managed up to now have been a few star trails. :tongue:

He’s wrong, I’ve seen plenty of examples done by mobile phone and there’s loads of stuff online about it e.g. https://science.nasa.gov/learn/heat/resource/a-guide-to-smartphone-astrophotography/
 

DaveReading

Don't suffer fools gladly (must try harder!)
Location
Reading, obvs
Perhaps he just meant that with a camera, you don't need 192 pages of instructions. ^_^

I'll ask him next time I see him.
 
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Legendary Member
Location
Devon & Die
As you’ll know that’s a style of photography I like to do. This one isn’t processed to my taste, it’s overly sharpened and (probably due to being a very dark sky area) there are just too many stars. The good astrophotographers I follow would have used some star reduction.

Your version is better, but, as you know, it's equally not something I'm drawn towards, even if I can appreciate the skill in capturing these types of scenes.
 

Pblakeney

Über Member
Perhaps he just meant that with a camera, you don't need 192 pages of instructions. ^_^

I'll ask him next time I see him.

Having tried Astro photography I can say that 192 pages is the minimum.
The notion of rocking up with a camera on a tripod and job done is the stuff of dreams.
 

nogoodnamesleft

Über Member
Interestingly, one of the local photo club members gave a talk yesterday evening on his astrophotography.

He made the observation that (so far), it's one of the few genres that can still only be done with a camera, and not a mobile phone - I wonder how long that will continue to be the case,

The talk included a very detailed account of how he shot an image of the Milky Way against Stonehenge, published in last month's Digital Camera World.

All I've ever managed up to now have been a few star trails. :tongue:
He’s wrong, I’ve seen plenty of examples done by mobile phone and there’s loads of stuff online about it e.g. https://science.nasa.gov/learn/heat/resource/a-guide-to-smartphone-astrophotography/
I agree with the local photo club member, but it maybe depends what you consider "astrophotography". The linked manual and smartphone images
I've seen have all been wide-field which is not what I'd call "astrophotography" but basically an image in a dark environment.

When it comes to what I'd call "astrophotography is images of astronomical objects which are generally not very bright and need exposures of hours. And for those exposures you generally you don't use high resolution sensors but want bigger pixels, as sensors warm and get noisier over long activity you often want cooling. And you need very accurate tracking (even correcting for PEC in your tracking mechanisms), then to stack large numbers of long exposure images. You need wide apertures to collect enough light, etc. These days you'd be using specialised filters eg to reduce light pollution.

And smartphone sensors are developing in the direction making them less suitable for astrophotography - increased pices counts, small sizes and compact everything (small apertures, etc.).

Even mounting a smartphone on a telescope and treating it as a basic sensor (ignoring the case it's mounted in) most are not the sort of sensor you'd want to take long exposure low photon images.

I'm all for encouraging people to look at what's left of the night sky and if that means pointing their smartphone for a widefield view of the sky then great but I suspect the talk comes down to what any individual considers "astrophotography".
 

Pross

Guru
I agree with the local photo club member, but it maybe depends what you consider "astrophotography". The linked manual and smartphone images
I've seen have all been wide-field which is not what I'd call "astrophotography" but basically an image in a dark environment.

When it comes to what I'd call "astrophotography is images of astronomical objects which are generally not very bright and need exposures of hours. And for those exposures you generally you don't use high resolution sensors but want bigger pixels, as sensors warm and get noisier over long activity you often want cooling. And you need very accurate tracking (even correcting for PEC in your tracking mechanisms), then to stack large numbers of long exposure images. You need wide apertures to collect enough light, etc. These days you'd be using specialised filters eg to reduce light pollution.

And smartphone sensors are developing in the direction making them less suitable for astrophotography - increased pices counts, small sizes and compact everything (small apertures, etc.).

Even mounting a smartphone on a telescope and treating it as a basic sensor (ignoring the case it's mounted in) most are not the sort of sensor you'd want to take long exposure low photon images.

I'm all for encouraging people to look at what's left of the night sky and if that means pointing their smartphone for a widefield view of the sky then great but I suspect the talk comes down to what any individual considers "astrophotography".

Deep space stuff is too technically complicated for me to try but I have seen examples taken using smartphones connected to a telescope. They not be as good but that's different to "impossible" as he apparently suggested. However, this bit from the OP led me to believe he was talking about wide field / astrolandscape photography "The talk included a very detailed account of how he shot an image of the Milky Way against Stonehenge, published in last month's Digital Camera World." Doing that sort of thing with a mobile phone is very achievable and no more technically complicated than doing it with a DSLR / mirrorless camera even if the results aren't as good quality.
 

Pross

Guru
Your version is better, but, as you know, it's equally not something I'm drawn towards, even if I can appreciate the skill in capturing these types of scenes.

Yep, although I still don't understand the view that if something isn't as you see it by eye then it is in some way not right (especially on a creative photography thread). Ultimately no photo portrays exactly what the eye sees as a camera lens and eye work so differently. In many cases a camera cannot come close to what the human eye does but when it comes to low light it is able to capture that extra detail and the images reflect the data that made it to the camera sensor / film that an element of skill and artistry has recovered. I'm not a big fan of using modified cameras and filters to accentuate certain colours (mainly reds) but again it is all data the photographer has captured and then their artistic choice.
 

nogoodnamesleft

Über Member
Deep space stuff is too technically complicated for me to try but I have seen examples taken using smartphones connected to a telescope. They not be as good but that's different to "impossible" as he apparently suggested. However, this bit from the OP led me to believe he was talking about wide field / astrolandscape photography "The talk included a very detailed account of how he shot an image of the Milky Way against Stonehenge, published in last month's Digital Camera World." Doing that sort of thing with a mobile phone is very achievable and no more technically complicated than doing it with a DSLR / mirrorless camera even if the results aren't as good quality.
I think of things like this as a continuum, a question of results and that can be a very personal assessment often (for some?) biased by who took the image (eg self, friend or profession, etc.).

You can do astrophotography using an old Kodak Instamatic on 126 film - but most wouldn't rate the results.

I once took some video of a Giant Black Asian Squirrel through a rather mucky birding telescope by holding my smartphone up against the eyepiece. Results I've saved as they are important to me on a personal level but photographically rubbish (I needed a lens with "reach" and my traditional camera I had with me only zoomed to 200mm on a smaller sensor).

Sensors make a big difference. Smartphone as built-in do a lot of processing on the image before you see it (often way OTT) and that masks a lot of the sensor limitations. Whereas a more photography oriented camera normally records a raw format which shown all the limitations and you then manually edit/process to sort the image. I've even found my 1" sensor limited for some indoor photography but you can notmally edit/process to sort out those limitations.

I admit to myself I'm too fussy, too much of a perfectionist.
 

Pross

Guru
The late Alyn Wallace, who inspired many amateurs to try their hand and astro landscapes, did this article. He died nearly 3 years ago and I'm not sure how long before that he did the article but it does show what can be achieved. He seems to have used his usual techniques such as stacking (he does say that the one phone did the stacking in camera) and even manages a panorama which, from the image showing how it was stitched, seems to have been done in RAW format. They're not as good as his usual stuff but are still better than most of what I've managed on a proper camera. They probably wouldn't be great quality as large prints (although they'll be compressed on his webpage) but would be fine on a calendar or for digital display. Next time I get clear skies I'll take a spare tripod to try shooting on my phone as well as my camera. I've done some aurora photos on my phone with decent results.

I agree regarding the in phone processing but would always shoot any kind of proper photo attempts on the phone in RAW anyway so only use the in-built processing for quick snapshots. There seems to be a generation of people in love with over-saturated images which I blame on Instagram and mobile phones, some sunset (and aurora) stuff you see is shockingly bad but seems to get loads of likes. Subtlety is a lost virtue (see the image Brian posted to start this debate!).
 
Top Bottom