Delivery Firms to be Liable for Vehicle Safety

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Drago

Legendary Member
Location
The Urban Fringe
Surely it would just be easier to ban the sales of the damn things rather than force responsibility onto businesses that the riders and bluff and bull sheet?

The bike the rider shows to the business isn't necessarily the one theyll be riding once theyre outmof view round the corner, and irs unfair that a diligent business thwt has done the requisite checks gets bent over for something a sly subcontractor has done behind their back.
 
Last edited:

Pat "5mph"

A kilogrammicaly challenged woman
Moderator
Location
Glasgow
Surely it would just be easier to ban the sales of the damn things
I've often asked myself how do the alleged black job market delivery riders get the funds to buy their bikes.
How do they maintain the bikes? Surely heavy use needs lots of bike consumables, not cheap I guess.
Who actually fixes those bikes? There are hardly any bike mechanic shops anymore, most of the ones still operating do not fix Ebikes.
Finally: where do they charge them or keep them overnight?
I wonder @Drago if there are other organizations that deal with those bikes, maybe the riders just rent them by the hour.
 
My interpretation is, and I am not a lawyer or solicitor so I may have misinterpreted is that it is an amendment to section 15 of the original 2006 act where section 15 is about employment rights which is now so extending out to push ownership onto the instructing firm in the chain, therefore removing the excuse that they are a subcontractor so it’s not their problem.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/13/crossheading/employment

Similar provisions are in the slavery act, off payroll working (IR35 legislation) and the recent changes to the Criminal Corporate Offence Act.
 

annedonnelly

Girl from the North Country
Location
Canonbie
I've often asked myself how do the alleged black job market delivery riders get the funds to buy their bikes.
How do they maintain the bikes? Surely heavy use needs lots of bike consumables, not cheap I guess.
Who actually fixes those bikes? There are hardly any bike mechanic shops anymore, most of the ones still operating do not fix Ebikes.
Finally: where do they charge them or keep them overnight?
I wonder @Drago if there are other organizations that deal with those bikes, maybe the riders just rent them by the hour.

Not e-bikes but when I volunteered at the city-centre bike repair charity we'd regularly get delivery riders in to have a puncture repaired at £10 a shot. It never seemed economic to us, all the time they were waiting for the repair they were losing out on work. None of them ever seemed keen to learn how to fix it themself.
 

Alex321

Guru
Location
South Wales
My interpretation is, and I am not a lawyer or solicitor so I may have misinterpreted is that it is an amendment to section 15 of the original 2006 act where section 15 is about employment rights which is now so extending out to push ownership onto the instructing firm in the chain, therefore removing the excuse that they are a subcontractor so it’s not their problem.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/13/crossheading/employment

Similar provisions are in the slavery act, off payroll working (IR35 legislation) and the recent changes to the Criminal Corporate Offence Act.

Yes, that is exactly what it is. Though using the word "ownership" is maybe not the right one to use, though I think I understand what you mean. And section 15 of that Act is not about employment rights, it is about penalties for employing people subject to immigration control.
 

Emanresu

I asked AI to show the 'real' me.
My interpretation is, and I am not a lawyer or solicitor so I may have misinterpreted is that it is an amendment to section 15 of the original 2006 act where section 15 is about employment rights which is now so extending out to push ownership onto the instructing firm in the chain, therefore removing the excuse that they are a subcontractor so it’s not their problem.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/13/crossheading/employment

Similar provisions are in the slavery act, off payroll working (IR35 legislation) and the recent changes to the Criminal Corporate Offence Act.

Perhaps a read across using Statutory Interpretation. New Labour were very good at this, seeding different laws with bits that could be read across to other older legislation. The average person may not see it, but the lawyers will.
 

mjr

Comfy armchair to one person & a plank to the next
Perhaps a read across using Statutory Interpretation. New Labour were very good at this, seeding different laws with bits that could be read across to other older legislation. The average person may not see it, but the lawyers will.
They usually at least mentioned it in some explanatory note or guidance, so it's disappointing if that's not been done this time.
 

Pat "5mph"

A kilogrammicaly challenged woman
Moderator
Location
Glasgow
At 430 Victoria Road, there's a shop which only handles these non-EAPC delivery bikes. It's called Bike Central.
Oh, I never noticed that shop!
Mind, one needs all one's wits about riding the Victoria Road cycle lane, I tend to look out for hazards, not shops lol
Anyway, illegal bikes but not illegal to service them when they are blatantly for use on public roads/cycle paths?
Probably! You couldn't make it up!
 

Oldhippy

Cynical idealist
In Canterbury centre you can see huddles of Deliveroo riders with these bikes that have batteries gaffer taped to the frame many with no chain at all to pedal. The Police seem to ignore them as they ride through the high street. They are clearly badged up as employed by Deliveroo with the back pack bags.
 

brommieinkorea

Über Member
Location
'Merica darnit
I've often asked myself how do the alleged black job market delivery riders get the funds to buy their bikes.
How do they maintain the bikes? Surely heavy use needs lots of bike consumables, not cheap I guess.
Who actually fixes those bikes? There are hardly any bike mechanic shops anymore, most of the ones still operating do not fix Ebikes.
Finally: where do they charge them or keep them overnight?
I wonder @Drago if there are other organizations that deal with those bikes, maybe the riders just rent them by the hour.

Spot on. So many "contractors" rent or lease their vehicle from the company they contract for , or the guy's brother in law etc... In the USA this is common practice in the trucking industry as well as food delivery and even parcel delivery. It has gotten so bad that California passed a law (AB5) reclassifying these workers as employees. The delivery companies/trucking companies use the independent contractor model to evade responsibility for everything from health insurance to employment taxes to collision liability. Trouble here is frequently foreign workers can't read the signs, and are a genuine road hazard because of it.
 

nogoodnamesleft

Über Member
I'm certainly all in favour of addressing these electric motorbikes (with token pedals, no type approvals, no insurance, no helmets, etc.) being taken off the road.

But, given they are already illegal yet the Police seem to not make much progress enforcing anything (never understood why), is a new law targeted at immigration actually going to result in them starting to actually enforce anything? Or maybe I'm just too cynical?
 

Big John

Legendary Member
I'm certainly all in favour of addressing these electric motorbikes (with token pedals, no type approvals, no insurance, no helmets, etc.) being taken off the road.

But, given they are already illegal yet the Police seem to not make much progress enforcing anything (never understood why), is a new law targeted at immigration actually going to result in them starting to actually enforce anything? Or maybe I'm just too cynical?

You're not too cynical. Laws are great but they have to be enforced. They're not. Illegal ebikes are everywhere and no one hides the fact either. They ride thru the centre of Stafford with impunity. Maybe the police simply don't have the resources.
 
Top Bottom