I do agree Paul - Cafe and Soapbox are the life of this forum, with Know How coming in behind, then Racing and then Beginners and Commuting.
Back in the olden days, C+ was driven by Know How and Beginners, with Cakestop / Soapbox coming up behind.
I know I went to the site for the Beginners info (and Commuting), and stayed there for Cakestop.
What IHMO we need to keep this place as a genuine cycle-focused site is the ability to attract new members whether it be through racing / know how / beginners (with beginners having the broadest appeal I would suggest), and the Cafe then would come second.....
This way around, I think it may struggle. A forum with no new members is destined to stagnate.....