I had to lie down in a darkened room...

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

shouldbeinbed

Rollin' along
Location
Manchester way
I am toying with the 8 speed, I am not mechanical at all and struggle with maintaining the rear dereailer without the cost of shop work. I was thinking about just popping on some Marathon Plus’s, SKS & racks and bobs ya uncle we have a tank of a commuter.

Only downsides I can tell is the weight, the lack of gears and the cost of servicing it.

weight: yes but barely noticable when riding along, and think of it as extra training,

lack of gears: No. simply a more efficient spread from top to bottom with no multiple overlap combinations doing exactly the same job inbetween. I can manage 90%+ of my regular uppy/downy routes on a 3 speed Brompton and 100% on an Alfine 8 700c Ute bike as I can on my old 3x8 CX or current 2x9 roadie.

cost of servicing: Couldn't tell you, I've only had the Alfine for 5 years so far, ridden thousands of miles in all weathers and road conditions.
New chain and a minor adjustment to the EBB by me is all its needed to keep it silent and smooth, I even had it assessed by a pro mechanic pal 18 months ago as a precaution, he refused to take my money as there was nothing he felt he could do to improve it.
 

simon.r

Person
Location
Nottingham
One other drawback with hub gears is fixing punctures. It's fiddly (but not impossible) to fix a puncture without disconnecting the gear cable.

They do make a lot of sense though, for all the other reasons listed on this thread.

If anyone fancies building a hub geared / disk braked bike up, On-One have their Pompetamine frames priced from £100 at the moment.
 

tyred

Squire
Location
Ireland
Can any of the people who think hub gears are too heavy, inefficient and slow match this guy's achievement?
Sturmey.jpg
 

vernon

Harder than Ronnie Pickering
Location
Meanwood, Leeds
One other drawback with hub gears is fixing punctures. It's fiddly (but not impossible) to fix a puncture without disconnecting the gear cable.


I've got vertical drop outs on my Rohlhoff hubbed Woodrup. Dropping the rear wheel out to do a puncture takes seconds longer than a conventional wheel. I simple unscrew the external indexing unit before removing the wheel and replace it after replacing the wheel. No faffing involved.
 
Doesn't need much washing with a set of 'Stayclean' pedals though, does it, Vern? :smile:
 

simon.r

Person
Location
Nottingham
I've got vertical drop outs on my Rohlhoff hubbed Woodrup. Dropping the rear wheel out to do a puncture takes seconds longer than a conventional wheel. I simple unscrew the external indexing unit before removing the wheel and replace it after replacing the wheel. No faffing involved.

My Shimano Nexus is obviously not as well designed:rolleyes: Detaching the gear cable to fully remove the rear wheel is a bit awkward and best done in workshop conditions. It's possible to fix a puncture without fully removing the wheel, which is what I tend to do by the roadside.
 

threebikesmcginty

Corn Fed Hick...
Location
...on the slake
I've got the Genesis Day 01 Alfine 8, it's a really nice bike, not the lightest but nicely put together and bowls along in a timely fashion. I run mine with guards, rack, 32 top contacts and a Brookes - it ain't a racer but it was never designed to be.
 

Sittingduck

Legendary Member
Location
Somewhere flat
So they're heavy, look weird and a problem if you get a puncture on the rear. Thanks but I'll stick to a normal road bike for all riding - Winter commuting or otherwise :thumbsup:
 
Top Bottom