Is the census of opinion that Ultegra is worth the extra money over a 105 groupset

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
Apologies for my naivety, but how is
isn't it just a different, rather than better, set-up? Or does tubeless confer some performance and/or puncture protection benefits that I'm unaware of?
Cheers.
It depends entirely on your priorities: punctures in tubeless tyres self-seal in most case, which to me is better than having to change a tube / repair one. Tuebless are slightly more fiddly to fit though, so that aspect isn't better.
 
OP
OP
Boyfrom64

Boyfrom64

Veteran
Location
Tamworth
@EasyPeez, I see you run a Genesis Equilibrium, so as someone who rides a steel frame bike, have you previously had a carbon / aluminium frame? If yes, is the ride of your equilibrium smoother than the other materials?
 
It depends entirely on your priorities: punctures in tubeless tyres self-seal in most case, which to me is better than having to change a tube / repair one. Tuebless are slightly more fiddly to fit though, so that aspect isn't better.

Ah, ok. On London-Paris recently my mate was riding tubeless and had a puncture right near the end. His didn't self-seal, just sprayed white gunk all over the street, then we had to put a tube in. I appreciate one anecdotal incident doesn't prove anything, so maybe he was just unlucky. I'd be keen to go tubeless myself if I thought the self-seal element worked well. Will have to do more reading.

@EasyPeez, I see you run a Genesis Equilibrium, so as someone who rides a steel frame bike, have you previously had a carbon / aluminium frame? If yes, is the ride of your equilibrium smoother than the other materials?
This is my first road bike so I have little to compare it to unfortunately. It's certainly smoother than my aluminium Land Rover MTB!!
I rode 20 miles on my mate's alu Synapse recently and his ride was definately 'softer' than mine - felt much comfier over the rough stuff but slightly less stiff and poised in terms of power transfer. My model has the cheaper Mjolnir steel plus carbon fork; I'd be interested to try the higher model Genesis' Reynolds 725 to see if I could tell the difference in weight/smoothness. I know steel is meant to give a better ride, but my ride can be pretty hard to be honest; I wouldn't be surprised if similar/higher priced alu and carbon frames were just as smooth or maybe smoother. That said, I tried an alu Super Evo when test riding and that was worse. Also a CAADX and that was definately softer (is that the same as smoother?!) but again less precise and poised. If I get chance to try any carbon or alu rides anytime soon I'll let you know how they compare. Cheers.
 

Eagone

Well-Known Member
Which one did you eventually go for the 4.3 or the 4.5?

I have today picked up the 4.5 and my decision was based on its looks - which are so darn secy I could marry it, if I weren't already married with 2 kids.

I also brought mine from Trek Coventry - what a guy (Chris) nothing was too much trouble - he's done me a fantastic deal and I've walked out feeling well looked after.
I brought a MTB from them earlier in the year and the service received has been fantastic - if your in the market for a new bike and live anywhere in the midlands - go here first.

Anyway as your from Tamworth I'll be looking out for another 4.5 or 4.3 at Rolliston Cafe over the next few weeks, assume you head out that way....
 
OP
OP
Boyfrom64

Boyfrom64

Veteran
Location
Tamworth
@Eagone I have not brought a bike yet. However, I am heading over to Trek Coventry later today as Chris has got me a Emonda SL5 to try out this weekend. Once I have ridden the bike, then I will decide which way to go Emonda or Domane.

I also brought mine from Trek Coventry - what a guy (Chris) nothing was too much trouble - he's done me a fantastic deal and I've walked out feeling well looked after.
I brought a MTB from them earlier in the year and the service received has been fantastic - if your in the market for a new bike and live anywhere in the midlands - go here first.

I have to second your comments about Chris. My wife Mandy, and I brought Mandy's bike from Trek Coventry and the service / help Chris gave Mandy in choosing a bike was second to none. I had not really considered Trek as an option before but now I do not see me buying another brand. So as @Eagone says, if you live in the Midlands then go pay Trek Coventry a visit.

Funnily enough, I have not made my way out to Rosiliston cafe; I ride out not to far from there on occassions but I have never stopped. However, now that Mandy has started riding, it is somewhere on my places to ride to, so hopefully I will see you there in the not too distant future... and on a Trek; but which one??
 
OP
OP
Boyfrom64

Boyfrom64

Veteran
Location
Tamworth
Bike ordered. I have gone for a Trek Emonda SL5; 2016 model in White, not Lime Green! thankfully, after test riding an Emonda over the weekend.
 
Top Bottom