Most Underrated film

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Flying_Monkey

Recyclist
Location
Odawa
"Bad Day at Black Rock"

http://en.wikipedia....y_at_Black_Rock

A western of sorts - but more about post-war America and the attitude to the Japanese.

Plus an amazing plot and acting. Highly recommended

It is - I almost put it on my Top 50.

In contrast to dell, I think Michael Mann is overrated by film critics. IMHO, he has technical facility but no heart.

Walter Hill, on the other hand, is generally underrated - The Driver is excellent, as is The Warriors - a personal favourite of mine.
 

Cletus Van Damme

Previously known as Cheesney Hawks
Which version, unedited or the Mellon Farmer edit :smile:


I really need to check this out I was not aware that there were 2 versions and I do not know which one I have. Which is the best by the way, unedited?
 
U

User169

Guest
It is - I almost put it on my Top 50.

In contrast to dell, I think Michael Mann is overrated by film critics. IMHO, he has technical facility but no heart.

Walter Hill, on the other hand, is generally underrated - The Driver is excellent, as is The Warriors - a personal favourite of mine.

I'd forgotten the warriors. Excellent movie.
 

Christopher

Über Member
LA Takedown - Michael Mann's study for Heat. Well worth a watch and better in many ways than Heat with a real Miami Vice feel to it.
Better than Heat I'd say. Shorter and with less waffle and no overacting from Pacino. I think the story is that Mann made LA Takedown for TV, and it did so well that he got $$$ to remake it as Heat.

My under-rated film is Gun Crazy: a 1950s B-movie noir with a strong plot and not one wasted frame or word of dialogue. It is taut and uncomprising, very good. Nasty too, but not gory.

Also an early animated film from that gut who did Spirited Away is Nausicaa: Valley of the Winds. The latter film is interesting as it isn't good vs evil, it's rather good, evil and also neutral guardians of a half-wrecked environment who'll stomp anyone who messes with the environment. Quite right too.
 

Flying_Monkey

Recyclist
Location
Odawa
Also an early animated film from that gut who did Spirited Away is Nausicaa: Valley of the Winds. The latter film is interesting as it isn't good vs evil, it's rather good, evil and also neutral guardians of a half-wrecked environment who'll stomp anyone who messes with the environment. Quite right too.

Hardly underrated though - well, maybe over this side of the world, but Ghibli films are practically a religion in Japan!
 

goo_mason

Champion barbed-wire hurdler
Location
Leith, Edinburgh
The 2004 Russian film, "Mars". It was very reminiscent of Jeunet's "Amelie" crossed with some of David Lynch's deftly weird touches.

From Wikipedia:

"Mars (Russian: Марс) is a 2004 Russian film, directed and written by Anna Melikian. Set in a small Russian city of Mars, the film tells the story of a professional boxer who has run away from his life to a small Russian town on the coast of the Black Sea.The story contains elements of surrealism and magical realism. The town's main industry is the manufacture of plush toys, which function as a local currency. The boxer is color blind; his color blindness is portrayed, for example, by a profusion of blue apples.

The city of Mars was formerly called Marks: Марс as opposed to Маркс, the name change being effected by removing one letter from the roof of the railway station."

I was sent a copy of the film by the Russian distributors after seeing it at the EIFF and emailing them to ask whether they planned a general UK release; I'm not sure whether or not it's ever been made available to the UK market, so I may have a rarity on my hands!
 

Christopher

Über Member
Lacombe Lucien
Obscure film from Louis Malle - I could only get it as part of a box set. It is about a rather petty man who tries to join the French Resistance in 1944 but gets turned down, so he becomes a collaborator out of sheer spite. It's unusual in that the real villans are horrible anti-Semitic French collaborators rather than the German occupiers. The co-incidences and little abuses of power are spot-on. There aren't any big battles, gunfights or explosions and certainly no heroics.

oh and Army of the Shadows is good too but isn't under-rated. And if I could only find Le Samourai at a reasonable price on DVD...
 
U

User482

Guest
Better than Heat I'd say. Shorter and with less waffle and no overacting from Pacino...

Gah. Why does he insist on being very quiet THEN ALL THE SHOUTING?!

He didn't do it earlier in his career - compare and contrast The Godfather with Devil's Advocate.
 

MontyVeda

a short-tempered ill-controlled small-minded troll
not being one who reads the film press or watches film programmes, I can't really say what is and isn't underrated... however I'd like to give a shout out for Le Donk & Scor-Zay-Zee. Worth a look in my book.
 

Yellow Fang

Legendary Member
Location
Reading
Just remembered Kidnapped, which was the Robert Louis Stevenson adventure. Michael Caine plays a Jacobean rebel, with a reasonably good Scottish accent I thought.
 
Top Bottom