Mountain Bike or Hybrid Bike?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
I'm looking for a bike mostly to stay active. I would go around my neighbourhood mostly on trails and go to the park on the grass and up hills and dirt roads. I would maybe take some adventures and bike through the city or take it to the ravine and go by the river where there are dirt trails and maybe a little bit off off roading if I take it camping. Majority of the time, it would just be around the neighbourhood.

I was looking at this bike at Sport Chek http://www.bikesfortherestofus.com/2010/11/jamis-hudson-3.html and I'm not really sure if it suits my uses and was concerned with the 3 gears.
- Jamis Hudson Easy 3 St 2014
Frame
6061 TIG-welded aluminum, Hudson laid-back design with low ride height,
Fork SR Suntour NEX4600-V2 suspension fork, alloy crown and sliders, 63mm travel
Headset Internal cup, threaded, 1 1/8”
Wheels/Hubs Shimano Nexus-7 rear and Formula alloy front QR hubs,
Alex C1000 alloy rims, 36H, 14g stainless steel spokes
Tires Jamis Sport Comfort, 26 x 1.95”, skinwall
Shifter Shimano Nexus RevoShift SL-7S10, 7-speed
Chain KMC Z51
Cog Shimano Nexus, 20T
Crankset Forged alloy crank, single 42T chainring, 170mm, with full length chainguard
BB Set Sealed cartridge, 68 x 122.5mm
Pedals Classic block-style
Brakes Tektro forged alloy direct pull brakes with Tektro alloy comfort levers
Handlebar Hi-rise comfort, 15º sweep x 80mm rise x 640mm wide
Stem Jamis alloy, 180mm quill x 80mm extension
Grips Kraton comfort
Seat Post Alloy micro-adjust, 31.6 x 350mm, with alloy QR clamp
Saddle Jamis Comfort with memory foam, synthetic suede top, bumper springs
Sizes M: S (13”), M (15)”, L (18”), XL (21”) F: S (14”), M (17”)
Color M: Blue Slate or Pearl White F: Seafoam or Pearl White

I also liked the Jamis Communter 1 Femme 2015 Bike but was skeptical of the thinner tires.
Frame: Hi-Tensile steel frame, new sloping design, kickstand/rack/fender mounts, forged dropouts with double eyelets
Fork: Jamis City/Cross Hi-tensile steel unicrown, straight blades, double dropout eyelets
Rear Derailleur: Shimano Altus, RD-M310 rear
Number of Gears: 7
Shifters: Shimano RevoShift SL-RS43, 7-Speed
Chainset: Forged alloy crank, 170mm, with full length chainguard
Chainrings: Single 44T chainring
Bottom Bracket: VP sealed 3RB bolt type axle, 35×52×39, 126mm
Cassette: Shimano MF-TZ31 7-Speed 14-34T
Chain: KMC Z7
Pedals: Comfort platform with TPE non-slip insert
Brakeset: Forged alloy linear-pull brakes
Brake Levers: Tektro CL330 ergonomic designed alloy brake lever
Handlebars: Jamis ARC, 6061 aluminum, 25.4 × 35 sweep x 580mm (F 14", 18") 600mm (M 15, 17, 19, 21, 23)
Stem: Jamis alloy hi-rise, quill type, 35 × 90mm with 180mm quill
Headset: Water-resistant sealed mechanism, threaded, 1 1/8
Grips: New Anatomic double density kraton grip with reflective end plug
Wheelset: Alex R-1000 alloy rims, 36H, Formula alloy hubs with QR and 14g stainless steel spokes
Front Tyre: CST Marathon/Tour with silver safety stripe, 700 × 32c
Rear Tyre: CST Marathon/Tour with silver safety stripe, 700 × 32c
Saddle: Jamis Metro Sport with synthetic suede cover, burnished sides and bumper springs with satin steel rails, gender specific
Seatpost: Jamis alloy micro-adjust, 25.4 × 350mm
Seat Binder: Alloy clamp and QR seatpin
Accessories: Full coverage 45mm fenders with adjustable stays with mud flaps, new designed Jamis carrier (capacity 18kg/40lbs.) with Jamis logo strap, rear reflector, micro bell and kickstand

In the mountain bike section of Sportchek, I was interested in:
http://www.sportchek.ca/product/index.jsp?productId=57539916
http://www.sportchek.ca/product/index.jsp?productId=57541946
http://www.sportchek.ca/product/index.jsp?productId=33583486

I've never had my own bike before and I want one to suit my needs for awhile but at the same time, stay within my budget! I also don't know anything about bikes so I'm seeking help!
 

Cavalol

Legendary Member
Location
Chester
Jamis Hudson Easy: looks (to me) more like a sort of low maintenance town bike than anything 'serious' for the type of riding you say you want to do, to be honest I'd give that a miss.
'Commuter': looks a bit more like it, but still wouldn't jump out to me as anything that's going to take sustained fairly hard use.

Diadora Savis: to be frank looks awful.
Helix: Looks a better bet
Trail X2: On appearance definitely the best of the bunch you've picked. It'll be heavier than the others but you'll get used to that and it should last a bit longer than the others.

Just my opinion, everyone's different!
 
OP
OP
B

bikebikebikebike

New Member
Jamis Hudson Easy: looks (to me) more like a sort of low maintenance town bike than anything 'serious' for the type of riding you say you want to do, to be honest I'd give that a miss.
'Commuter': looks a bit more like it, but still wouldn't jump out to me as anything that's going to take sustained fairly hard use.

Diadora Savis: to be frank looks awful.
Helix: Looks a better bet
Trail X2: On appearance definitely the best of the bunch you've picked. It'll be heavier than the others but you'll get used to that and it should last a bit longer than the others.

Just my opinion, everyone's different!

Thanks! You made that so straight forward and easy for me!
 

Tin Pot

Guru
I'm not familiar with the U.S. Market, being from the UK, but I would look at a hardtail or a hybrid.

The first listed won't really handle muddy hollows and tree roots.

The trail x2 you e listed could fit the bill, but I can't speak for the brand or model as I've not heard of them.

Specialized are a "standard", so here's one of their hybrids
http://m.specialized.com/us/en/bikes/multi-use/crosstrail/crosstrail

And one of their mtbs, the Rockhopper
http://m.specialized.com/us/en/bikes/mountain/rockhopper/rockhopper-29
 
Top Bottom