Crankarm gets 10/10 for his post.
I played around with the seatpost I accidentally bought. It's a HL Corp SP-79. It took the worst of the bumps in the roads out and reduced the vibration from the bad surfaces. Even when the tensioning adjustment was on maximum it tended to bounce a bit and bottom out on the worst bumps - quite uncomfortable.
I'm sure the inability to get it quite right is because I'm too heavy for it, so I looked at the spec on the Cushy SL Post Moderne that Crankarm wrote about, decided that at £15 I couldn't go wrong and bought one.
I'm at the upper weight limit for the standard spring, so just need to avoid eating too many pies. I've used it a number of times and can't improve on what Crankarm has said. It is an excellent device.
I did need to adjust the spring tension to near maximum, and also put 1/2 turn on the adjuster that stops lateral movement. Apart from that it just went on and worked.
So thank you Crankarm for a good recommendation. As the
Evans sell off seems to be end of line I may now have to buy another one as a spare - usual story....
As I now have a surplus saddle (Spoon) surplus suspension seatpost and a spare clamp for it which I don't need I feel a for sale ad coming on.