Hi, I bought a Scarp 1 and used it 3 nights so far. One night in driving rain & high winds, one night in still cold conditions and one in mild breezy conditions ( all Scotland ). Excellent tent and what I'd describe as an "Akto Plus".
Plus sides in no particular order:
Very roomy inner, longer than most with good head and foot height at the ends compared to the Akto. 2 porches give great flexibility for storage, cooking, access and views, packs really small and light. You shouldn't need the winter poles most of the time as its already in effect an 11 pole tent with the ends braced really well giving great stability.
Things to watch/tweak:
You'll need to seam seal it before use, no great hassle but essential as it leaks if you don't. Quite delicate in construction compared to Hilleberg and not as consistently finished ( but then its cheaper ) so you have to treat it with a bit more care.
Add cords to all zippers and a hanging line inside plus 2 guys for the main hoop and carry 2 extra pegs than supplied accordingly. Go for the solid inner as it still has upper mesh panels ( I'd have preferred a winter option to close the mesh completely but haven't used it in snow as yet to see how cold it gets.
Other than that so far its been a great tent to use, very impressed and prefer it over my previous Akto and Soulo I've owned in same category ( it falls somewhere in between in terms of breadth of performance and weight for all year round use ).
Lastly I had to ask Henry Shires for some advice and got amazingly quick email support-really refreshing and bespoke service compared to the "big brands" which is a nice touch too.
Hope that helps and dont hesitate to ask if you have any questions
Andrew