Long story as short as possible, the old dear gets a letter a while ago from HMRC stating that she had a modest tax refund pending with instructions as to how to claim it online.
We go to the gov.uk web address, enter some personal details for verification (NI number, DOB etc) then it wants to take us to her online banking portal via some third party intermediary.
At the portal I enter all the details used to login to her online banking account and go through 2FA. Before I commit I hesitate as the whole thing stinks of a scam; with the need to provide your full login details simply to receive a refund seeming highly suspicious.
I stop short of submitting the details. I can't contact HMRC for verification as it's the weekend so ring the bank, get through to fraud (who agree it all sounds highly suspicious although can't confirm whether the website linked to in their name was legit) and a block is placed on internet banking.
Fast forward to yesterday and I finally get the chance to call HMRC. After predictably sitting on the phone forever they confirm that the letter is legit; along with the web address it gives for the refund, the refund amount etc. I've subsequently wasted another hour or so on the phone (mostly on hold) to TSB (bloody useless; avoid like the plague) getting her account unblocked.
As I was keen to drive home to the bloke at HMRC; how absolutely ridiculous it is to have to enter your full online banking details just to receive a refund; for which only account number and sort code are actually required. Surely by doing so you're a) causing people to unnecessarily expose their login credentials to a third party; this increasing the risk of being compromised, and b) conditioning people to the idea that this is the norm; when bogus websites touting refunds and stipulating that you need to login to claim are a well-known method of harvesting people's login details so that their accounts can subsequently be emptied.
Does anyone else think this is utterly ridiculous; especially coming from a supposedly respectable and trustworthy government agency...?
We go to the gov.uk web address, enter some personal details for verification (NI number, DOB etc) then it wants to take us to her online banking portal via some third party intermediary.
At the portal I enter all the details used to login to her online banking account and go through 2FA. Before I commit I hesitate as the whole thing stinks of a scam; with the need to provide your full login details simply to receive a refund seeming highly suspicious.
I stop short of submitting the details. I can't contact HMRC for verification as it's the weekend so ring the bank, get through to fraud (who agree it all sounds highly suspicious although can't confirm whether the website linked to in their name was legit) and a block is placed on internet banking.
Fast forward to yesterday and I finally get the chance to call HMRC. After predictably sitting on the phone forever they confirm that the letter is legit; along with the web address it gives for the refund, the refund amount etc. I've subsequently wasted another hour or so on the phone (mostly on hold) to TSB (bloody useless; avoid like the plague) getting her account unblocked.
As I was keen to drive home to the bloke at HMRC; how absolutely ridiculous it is to have to enter your full online banking details just to receive a refund; for which only account number and sort code are actually required. Surely by doing so you're a) causing people to unnecessarily expose their login credentials to a third party; this increasing the risk of being compromised, and b) conditioning people to the idea that this is the norm; when bogus websites touting refunds and stipulating that you need to login to claim are a well-known method of harvesting people's login details so that their accounts can subsequently be emptied.
Does anyone else think this is utterly ridiculous; especially coming from a supposedly respectable and trustworthy government agency...?
Last edited:
