The HMRC tax refund non-scam

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

wafter

I like steel bikes and I cannot lie..
Location
Oxford
Long story as short as possible, the old dear gets a letter a while ago from HMRC stating that she had a modest tax refund pending with instructions as to how to claim it online.

We go to the gov.uk web address, enter some personal details for verification (NI number, DOB etc) then it wants to take us to her online banking portal via some third party intermediary.

At the portal I enter all the details used to login to her online banking account and go through 2FA. Before I commit I hesitate as the whole thing stinks of a scam; with the need to provide your full login details simply to receive a refund seeming highly suspicious.

I stop short of submitting the details. I can't contact HMRC for verification as it's the weekend so ring the bank, get through to fraud (who agree it all sounds highly suspicious although can't confirm whether the website linked to in their name was legit) and a block is placed on internet banking.

Fast forward to yesterday and I finally get the chance to call HMRC. After predictably sitting on the phone forever they confirm that the letter is legit; along with the web address it gives for the refund, the refund amount etc. I've subsequently wasted another hour or so on the phone (mostly on hold) to TSB (bloody useless; avoid like the plague) getting her account unblocked.

As I was keen to drive home to the bloke at HMRC; how absolutely ridiculous it is to have to enter your full online banking details just to receive a refund; for which only account number and sort code are actually required. Surely by doing so you're a) causing people to unnecessarily expose their login credentials to a third party; this increasing the risk of being compromised, and b) conditioning people to the idea that this is the norm; when bogus websites touting refunds and stipulating that you need to login to claim are a well-known method of harvesting people's login details so that their accounts can subsequently be emptied.

Does anyone else think this is utterly ridiculous; especially coming from a supposedly respectable and trustworthy government agency...?
 
Last edited:

Brandane

Miles cannot be done unless moving!
Location
Costa Clyde.
Does anyone else think this is utterly ridiculous; especially coming from a supposedly respectable and trustworthy government agency...?

Yes.
 

Me too. The strange thing is, that you can get a winter fuel payment paid directly into your bank so why not an HMRC refund ?
Come to think about it, when I had a refund from HMRC it was`nt, it was done through the company payroll.
I had something similar to what you have said, not HMRC but NS&I. I had hot sweats thinking it was a scam. They say that God works in mysterious ways, God is not alone.
 

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Photo Winner
Location
Inside my skull
I think it is online verification of who you are, rather than payment. It obviously is not needed for payment. It will stop someone using your NI details etc, to pay your refund into their account.

Under the plans, people will be able to verify their identity by securely signing into their online banking account, rather than relying solely on existing identity checks.

The Government says the additional method will make it easier for people who struggle to prove who they are using traditional documents or digital verification.
 

SpokeyDokey

69, & my GP says I will officially be old at 70!
Moderator
My HMRC account uses the government gateway which is meant to be secure. You can also use the gov.uk one to log in which I used for my NHS app.

I guess you checked in there ?

I use the Gov Gateway login for HMRC.

I also had to set up 'gov.uk one' login to get my 70 years of age driving licence - didn't know it could also be used for the NHS App, too.

After a quick search it seems that there are a huge number of government services for which it can be used as a login tool:

https://home.account.gov.uk/services-using-one-login
 

Gunk

Guru
Location
Oxford
Long story as short as possible, the old dear gets a letter a while ago from HMRC stating that she had a modest tax refund pending with instructions as to how to claim it online.

We go to the gov.uk web address, enter some personal details for verification (NI number, DOB etc) then it wants to take us to her online banking portal via some third party intermediary.

At the portal I enter all the details used to login to her online banking account and go through 2FA. Before I commit I hesitate as the whole thing stinks of a scam; with the need to provide your full login details simply to receive a refund seems highly suspicious.

I stop short of submitting the details. I can't contact HMRC for verification as it's the weekend so ring the bank, get through to fraud (who agree it all sounds highly suspicious although can't confirm whether the website linked to in their name was legit) and a block is placed on internet banking.

Fast forward to yesterday and I finally get the chance to call HMRC. After predictably sitting on the phone forever they confirm that the letter is legit; along with the web address it gives for the refund, the refund amount etc. I've subsequently wasted another hour or so on the phone (mostly on hold) to TSB (bloody useless; avoid like the plague) getting her account unblocked.

As I was keen to drive home to the bloke at HMRC; how absolutely ridiculous it is to have to enter your full online banking details just to receive a refund; for which only account number and sort code are actually required. Surely by doing so you're a) causing people to unnecessarily expose their login credentials to a third party; this increasing the risk of being compromised, and b) conditioning people to the idea that this is the norm; when bogus websites touting refunds and stipulating that you need to login to claim are a well-known method of harvesting people's login details so that their accounts can subsequently be emptied.

Does anyone else think this is utterly ridiculous; especially coming from a supposedly respectable and trustworthy government agency...?

I’ve helped both my kids get small tax refunds using this method and it was fine.
 

Dadam

Veteran
Location
SW Leeds
Does anyone else think this is utterly ridiculous; especially coming from a supposedly respectable and trustworthy government agency...?

Not really. They've just modernised the service this year. More details here

As long as you went to an address ending in gov.uk it's safe. Clicking on a link in an email to launch it is dubious practice even if legit, but typing it in gives you chance to make sure it's a legit URL. Even better, find the relevant site yourself as I just did. To be doubly sure you can check the certificate is issued to the right domain by clicking on the icon next to the address bar: Chrome example here:



1795267844820.png


1795267726884.png
 

13 rider

Legendary Member
Location
leicester
Talking off Government waste ,today I received a letter to tell me I will be eligible for my state pension on my 67th birthday ( nothing I didn't know ) this in in seven years and 5 months time . The letter dosnt tell me how much I will get ,whats the point of this letter
 

annedonnelly

Girl from the North Country
Location
Canonbie
My friend recently told me he'd had to do that. He's not very IT savvy and was concerned about it. I said it sounded odd - why didn't they just ask for sort code & account number. He did confirm that it was a .gov.uk site so it seemed like it was ok, but in these days of widespread scamming and encouraging people to take care it seems strange to me.
 

Fastpedaller

Veteran
Location
Norfolk
Talking off Government waste ,today I received a letter to tell me I will be eligible for my state pension on my 67th birthday ( nothing I didn't know ) this in in seven years and 5 months time . The letter dosnt tell me how much I will get ,whats the point of this letter

I had one years ago stating similar, and that I'd paid enough to receive full pension....... Five years later got another saying I was short of contributions!

In the intervening 5 years they had 'moved the goalposts'...... Just saying :sad:
 
Top Bottom