A good helmet camera?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

BSRU

A Human Being
Location
Swindon
My review of the Sony HDR-AS15

Pros.
The video quality is excellent and watching 1080p at 30fps and 720p at 120fps is amazing.
The low light capability is exceptional, vastly superior to my GoPro Hero 2 with ProTune turned on. Since the new Hero 3 is only twice as good as a Hero 2(non-ProTune) in low light conditions then the Sony should by far the superior low light camera.
The LCD on the side makes it easy to change settings without the need for any other device.
The waterproof case is very sold and very well made(also a con).
Excellent battery life, uses a fairly standard Sony battery with OEM batteries already in existence( alot cheaper than official batteries(14 pound for two batteries and a charger)
A time indicator on the LCD to inform you of how much recording time is left on the memory card.
One button press start, press the record button and it starts recording from off in a couple of seconds, has a slider to lock start/stop button.
Seems to be pretty much firmware bug free from new(unlike GoPro's and a much lesser extent Contour).
It is perfect as a bike mounted camera.

Cons
Non-rotating lens and has to be upright, cannot be upside down.
No resistance to rain so the waterproof case is always required.
Waterproof case also required to mount it on a bike, currently no other option.
Not a helmet camera, far too heavy with the headband mount and waterproof case.(A new headband mount that holds the camera directly is not available yet and not compatible with the waterproof headband mount)
The waterproof case has a BIG fogging problem, anit-fog sheets not available for another three weeks(no idea if they will work).
The beeps are very quite so almost inaudible when in the waterproof case.
Just one small LED to indicate it is recording, which is difficult to see if not looking directly at the back of the camera.
The micro SDHC slot allows the user to put the memory card in upside down(at least a warning icon will flash when it is turned on, assuming you are looking at the LCD).
Cannot record and charge at the same time as no access to USB port when mounted.

Overall it has made me reconsider buying the a Hero 3 when it goes on sale, although the 2.7k recording seems very interesting and whilst waiting for Contour to bring out a new camera to match the Sony/Hero 3 I will not wait for ever and another Sony maybe be purchased.
 

Rezillo

TwoSheds
Location
Suffolk
Thanks for the review. Looks as if Sony have a good cam but need to work on their mounting systems and ports - not just usb as the external mike socket is also inaccessible with the case on.

A few questions - Will it work with a usb supply, putting aside the access issue? What is the battery life like? - you say it is excellent but what time is typical? Is there any wind noise if the case is not used? (seemed to be a lot of wind noise on one youtube video).

Thanks.
 

BSRU

A Human Being
Location
Swindon
Thanks for the review. Looks as if Sony have a good cam but need to work on their mounting systems and ports - not just usb as the external mike socket is also inaccessible with the case on.

A few questions - Will it work with a usb supply, putting aside the access issue? What is the battery life like? - you say it is excellent but what time is typical? Is there any wind noise if the case is not used? (seemed to be a lot of wind noise on one youtube video).

Thanks.
I have not tried charging and recording at the same time, I will read the manual and give it a go at the weekend.
I have not tried a battery test, hopefully again I will try at the weekend. The longest ride I have used it for in 1080p/30fps mode is 1hr 45mins.The problem being if the battery runs out whilst riding I have know way of knowing, the beeps are too quiet and recording led is to small.
I have not really checked wind noise as it is in the case and I know the sound will be muffled, plus when using it at 720p/120fps no sound is recorded.
 

Rezillo

TwoSheds
Location
Suffolk
I have not tried charging and recording at the same time, I will read the manual and give it a go at the weekend.
I have not tried a battery test, hopefully again I will try at the weekend. The longest ride I have used it for in 1080p/30fps mode is 1hr 45mins.The problem being if the battery runs out whilst riding I have know way of knowing, the beeps are too quiet and recording led is to small.
I have not really checked wind noise as it is in the case and I know the sound will be muffled, plus when using it at 720p/120fps no sound is recorded.

Thanks - nearly two hours, and possibly more, at 1080p is good.
 

BSRU

A Human Being
Location
Swindon
I used the Sony camera for 2hrs and 10mins today using 1080p at 30fps, still a little battery power left but not much.
 

Rezillo

TwoSheds
Location
Suffolk
The new Gopro Black Edition does 1080p at 60fps. It is, however, £365.

The Sony AS10 (non-wifi version of AS15) is £130 delivered on Ebay. I've gone for it - BSRU's review and the quality of online videos made a good case, imho. I'm sure I can bodge some mount variations for it
 

BSRU

A Human Being
Location
Swindon
The new Gopro Black Edition does 1080p at 60fps. It is, however, £365.

The Sony AS10 (non-wifi version of AS15) is £130 delivered on Ebay. I've gone for it - BSRU's review and the quality of online videos made a good case, imho. I'm sure I can bodge some mount variations for it
For such a high quality camera it's a real bargain at that price, I'm almost tempted myself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gaz

gaz

Cycle Camera TV
Location
South Croydon
For such a high quality camera it's a real bargain at that price, I'm almost tempted myself.
I'm extremely tempted!
 

Miquel In De Rain

No Longer Posting
Not the point really,the point is battery life,water proofness and ease of fitting.Don't want a camera too bulky,plus quality of course.The GoPro's on the tour lasted about two and a half hours and that was it.No good for long rides but ok for commuting I guess.I have one cam but it seems too bulky wired and too fiddly to fit on a helmet.Need something which takes two AA or maybe two AAA would be better instead of rubbish internal batteries which wear out.

No,im not happy with the go pro's,I have enough junk on my handlebars and I saw first hand on the tour how effective they were for recording all day although the quality was very good.

The best I have seen is this,with the possibility of spare batteries and waterproofness.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/WATERPROO...ctronics_Video_Camcorders&hash=item46098d0114
 

Miquel In De Rain

No Longer Posting

gaz

Cycle Camera TV
Location
South Croydon
The Sony looks stunning in those night shots. however it appears to have a bad fisheye and the lack of mounts is a deal breaker for me at this moment in time.
 

BSRU

A Human Being
Location
Swindon
The Sony looks stunning in those night shots. however it appears to have a bad fisheye and the lack of mounts is a deal breaker for me at this moment in time.
I had not noticed any problems with fish eye when reviewing my own footage, although until yesterday I have been using the image stabilisation which limits the FOV to 120.
Bike mounting is not a problem for me as I have RAM with a camera tripod mount for both front and rear cameras.
I really want a similar quality camera that is suited to being mounted flat on top of a helmet. My Contour Plus is becoming more and more useless this time of year, by the time next year it can be used it will have been made obsolete by a replacement.
 
Top Bottom