A question for helmet wearers

Discussion in 'Helmet Discussions' started by jefmcg, 18 Oct 2017.


I'm a helmet user and I ....

Poll closed 25 Oct 2017.
  1. ...think helmets should be compulsory.

    6 vote(s)
  2. ...do not think helmets should be compulsory.

    46 vote(s)
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. From another thread:

    I've never heard this before, and I don't believe it is true. So, an non-scientific survey. Please, only vote if you wear a helmet regularly though not necessarily for every ride.

    For the record, I often wear a helmet, I learned to ride under compulsory helmet laws and do not believe they should be compulsory.

    There's a whole other thread to discuss compulsion, this thread is to see if the attitude of helmet wearers skews as the above quote suggests.
    TinyMyNewt and velovoice like this.
  2. I like Skol

    I like Skol I'm adamant I haven't got any PPI....

    Not an answer to your question but maybe a relevant point.

    A colleague in my office walked in wearing this the other day;


    He isn't (wasn't) a cyclist in the slightest but without consulting any of the regular cyclists in the office he has sold his car and bought a secondhand bike to ride the 3 mile trip to and from work. Luckily he seems to have bagged a good bike, but what made him think he needed to wear a helmet? Is the public perception so deeply ingrained that they cannot possibly imagine doing something as risky as riding a bike without one?
    raleighnut and potsy like this.
  3. sight-pin

    sight-pin Über Member

    Floating about
    It's just the same old story really. When i used to ride motorbikes i never wore a helmet as it wasn't compulsory back then, would i wear one now if i was riding motorbikes? Too right i would. It will become compulsory at some time in the future for cyclist without doubt. I'm a helmet user but don't think it should be mandatory.
    Cycleops likes this.
  4. numbnuts

    numbnuts Legendary Member

    North Baddesley
    Where the “I couldn't care a …. on what others do option”
  5. I like Skol

    I like Skol I'm adamant I haven't got any PPI....

    Totally different scenarios! Motorbikes are usually capable of speeds in excess of 100mph, with obvious consequences if it goes wrong. Most cyclists are rather pleased with themselves if they get close to 30mph.
    Anyway, this is going off-topic from the OP and as I don't wear a helmet unless it is to satisfy entry conditions of an event I really want to do then I can't comment on the OPs question any further.
  6. Spinney

    Spinney Bimbleur extraordinaire

    Under the Edge
    Mod note:
    As pointed out above, some posts here are already off topic.
    If you are not a helmet wearer, then the poll is not for you and there is no need to comment in this thread.
    david k and jefmcg like this.
  7. sight-pin

    sight-pin Über Member

    Floating about
    They was capable of well over 100 mph back then as well.
  8. I don't mind the off topic posts, as they keep my thread alive :wub:, but it's really all been done to death in the linked to thread.
  9. Daddy Pig

    Daddy Pig Über Member

    I think it should be left for the individual to decide, I would use one however I have smashed a helmets few in my time. The result would have been not being here today, but at least for adults it's their own risk and responsibility. As a father, I would insist on my children using them. I could see it being made compulsory for say the under 16s.
    Sharky likes this.
  10. tonyg52

    tonyg52 Guest

    I wear a helmet, what other people do doesn't concern me.
    Dayvo, wisdom and numbnuts like this.
  11. CanucksTraveller

    CanucksTraveller Macho Business Donkey Wrestler

    Hitchin, Herts
    I'm a regular helmet wearer and I'm entirely pro-choice, as are the other members of the group that I ride with. I wouldn't ever want to compel others to wear, in fact I'd oppose any push to make helmets compulsory.

    I was also surprised at Smokin Joe's assertion on the other thread, it doesn't ring true for me.
    david k likes this.
  12. Fonze

    Fonze Totally obsessive , cool by nature

    I wear a helmet.
    I never used to and was riding my mtb up a slope and fell , I got a nice lump the size of a golf ball and a decent sized cut.
    I'm naturally clumsy and so decided I would wear one.
    I personally believe it should be a choice thing but I'm not keen seeing young kids without one, it's just my opinion.
    david k likes this.
  13. Yes, sure, but I'm not bothering a lot of strangers with that question.

    90% is pretty strong. If it really was more than 50% amongst the general helmet-wearing cyclist community, I'd expect more than 10% here. Of course any self-selected online survey is going to get skewed results. Yes, I am looking at you, Halfods.

    I didn't make the original claim. If I was trying to prove it, I would work a little harder. I was just curious to see if it seemed to be true. I had a pretty good result from a similar survey about "offs" a few months ago. It's more for @Smokin Joe to prove it rather than for me to disprove it. I'm guessing he's not interested enough to do it, so I conducted this low-energy survey.
  14. And it moved from 10 to 17% while this post was awaiting moderation :smile:

    It's just interesting, to me at least, not proof I will take to social media.
  15. Reiver

    Reiver Legendary Member

    certain roads and conditions I wear a helmet but 95% of the time I don't. So if I can be considered to be a helmet wearer I definitely don't want compulsion. I see no need whatsoever to wear a lid whilst pootling along some single track road at 10mph and seeing may be a car every 5 mile. But a busy urban road in the winter I feel they are important.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice