Cyclist killed in road rage incident

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Crankarm

Guru
Location
Nr Cambridge
This was posted on the Cyclechat forum. The link to the Coventry Telegraph was a bit slow and it seems to have been missed so have reposted below. Absolutely horrific.

Cyclist killed by driver for damaging wing mirror, court told



Apr 21 2009

By Duncan Gibbons



A CYCLIST was knocked down and killed in a suspected revenge attack after he damaged a motorist's wing mirror, a court has heard.
The car driver, Sean Fitzgerald, aged 35, of Bennetts Road North, Keresley, Coventry, is charged with murder.
He is alleged to have deliberately mounted the pavement and driven at warehouseman Paul Webb on Thursday afternoon.
The 42-year-old victim suffered multiple injuries and died at the scene in Bennetts Road South, Keresley, as he cycled home from work at the Co-op distribution centre at PrologisPark.
Coventry magistrates court was told Fitzgerald reacted after his nearside mirror was knocked off by a cyclist moments earlier, but it is not clear if the victim was the man responsible.

Emma Garnett, prosecuting, said: “He was angry that his wing mirror was knocked off.
“This defendant followed the cyclist for 300 yards from the first point of contact and mounted the kerb while he [Mr Webb] was on the pavement.”
She said the cyclist suffered a fatal combination of broken ribs, a shattered pelvis and internal bleeding in the crash, which left debris scattered up to 15 metres away.
The court heard Fitzgerald handed himself in to police the following day where he was arrested and charged.
Andrew Mithie, defending, said: “This gentleman was driving from Bennetts Road North into the city centre along Bennetts Road South when there was contact by a cyclist with his nearside wing mirror.
“He was upset about the damage and started to remonstrate with the cyclist who made off.
“This gentleman accepts that some distance away there was contact and it seems that it probably was the same individual, but he’s not sure if it was or not.”
Dad of two Fitzgerald was denied bail and was remanded in custody for a hearing at Coventry Crown Court on Monday April 27.
Police are still seeking witnesses to the accident.
Detective Inspector Wendy Bailey from CID at Little Park Street police station said: “The victim was wearing a red jacket and the car he collided with was silver in colour.
"It is believed the car involved was behind a refuse collection lorry.
"We would appeal for anyone who saw the pedal cyclist or the silver car behind the refuse lorry to come forward.”
Anyone who witnessed the collision or anyone with information is urged to call Little Park Street police station on 0845 113 5000.
 
D

Deleted member 1258

Guest
Happened round the corner from me on a road I use a lot
 

eddiemee

Well-Known Member
Jesus, that's scary as hell. It's appalling enough that the driver committed murder, even worse that the poor guy he hit may not even have been his intended target. One hopes that if he's found guilty he will get a proper sentence.

RIP Mr Webb.
 

dudi

Senior Member
Location
Ipswich, Suffolk
for god's sake, not a nother one!

what is it with these people? why are they so angry all the time?
What ever happened to rational thought?
****tards.
 
Randochap said:
HolySh!t!

Motorized murder! The infernal combustion engine imparts super powers to cowards.

Murder infers the driver took the vehicle onto the road with intent to take a life. The most he could be charged with is manslaughter as he will argue that his actions were purely a reaction to the cyclist taking his mirror off IMO.

I guess if you are going to argue to the toss with someone in control of a tonne and a half of motorised metal, make sure that you have a get out route, or you are in charge of a larger lump of motorised metal.

Taking a wing mirror off someones car will cost them £150-£250+ to replace nowadays. Whilst I can't understand why the driver managed to lose it in such a big way, I can understand why he was upset when the rider made off afterwards.

Without the detail of what led up to the cyclist taking the mirror off, we have no idea of where the aggression originated from.

Another life lost on the roads for such a stupid reason - such a waste :biggrin:
 

asterix

Comrade Member
Location
Limoges or York
very-near said:
Murder infers the driver took the vehicle onto the road with intent to take a life. The most he could be charged with is manslaughter as he will argue that his actions were purely a reaction to the cyclist taking his mirror off IMO.

I guess if you are going to argue to the toss with someone in control of a tonne and a half of motorised metal, make sure that you have a get out route, or you are in charge of a larger lump of motorised metal.

Taking a wing mirror off someones car will cost them £150-£250+ to replace nowadays. Whilst I can't understand why the driver managed to lose it in such a big way, I can understand why he was upset when the rider made off afterwards.

Without the detail of what led up to the cyclist taking the mirror off, we have no idea of where the aggression originated from.

Another life lost on the roads for such a stupid reason - such a waste :biggrin:


So, a fairly minor offence then, with extenuating circumstances?

LLB your foolishness knows no bounds..
 

John the Monkey

Frivolous Cyclist
Location
Crewe
very-near said:
Murder infers the driver took the vehicle onto the road with intent to take a life. The most he could be charged with is manslaughter as he will argue that his actions were purely a reaction to the cyclist taking his mirror off IMO.

I guess if you are going to argue to the toss with someone in control of a tonne and a half of motorised metal, make sure that you have a get out route, or you are in charge of a larger lump of motorised metal.

Taking a wing mirror off someones car will cost them £150-£250+ to replace nowadays. Whilst I can't understand why the driver managed to lose it in such a big way, I can understand why he was upset when the rider made off afterwards.

Without the detail of what led up to the cyclist taking the mirror off, we have no idea of where the aggression originated from.

Another life lost on the roads for such a stupid reason - such a waste :biggrin:

Words fail me.
 
asterix said:
So, a fairly minor offence then, with extenuating circumstances?

LLB your foolishness knows no bounds..

No it is not 'a fairly minor offence'. Taking the guys mirror off was 'a fairly minor offence', and the drivers reaction was unforgivable. I am not defending his extreme reaction to this and hope his sentence reflects what he has done - taken another life in a fit of temper, but murder is premeditated/planned, and that is not the actions of a road rage incident explained in this way.
 

the reluctant cyclist

Über Member
Location
Birmingham
I would be surprised if the Police would charge him with murder if they thought that only a charge of manslaughter would stick.

As for the premeditated bit - surely the fact that he gave chase and mounted the pavement was "intent to kill"?
 
Linf, just stop it. We do not have all of the evidence. From the reporting it is not clear what happened.

For all we know the driver might have passed the cyclist too close and caused the wing mirror to be knocked off when hitting the cyclist. The cyclist may have then tried to get away from the driver, seeing how angry he was, and the car may have chased him and mowed him down.

Would you agree that this is a possible scenario? Of course it may have been a militant cyclist who didn't like the look of the car and decided to hit the wing mirror off for fun. Or the reporting might be entirely wrong and the wing mirror may only have been folded back (amazingly papers get it wrong!!!).

So I suggest we leave this argument until the facts are know. Kapish?
 

nilling

Über Member
Location
Preston, UK
So much red mist - the driver is not sure whether the cyclist he mowed down was the one who knocked his wing mirror off! A truly horrific incident :biggrin:
 
Bloomin Hell (Or Stronger Words to that effect) :biggrin:
A couple of years ago in the middle of winter/ heavy rain/ poor visibility I clipped a wing mirror of a car stuck in traffic :biggrin: I instantly went back to fix it was greeted with a nice smile from a pretty young woman (the driver). The reaction of the driver in the OP was unbelievable.
 
Top Bottom