Different bikes suit different people, I used to race on a ALU Cannondale CX9 at the time its seemed ok and was happy with it as I knew no different. . When my daughter started racing I built up a carbon bike from a frame, cant remember the model but it was the fore-runner to the Dedacciai Super Cross, what a difference, the Cannondale felt like a ageing old dog compared to it, the carbon felt like a lively springer spaniel.