From a scale of 7 to 10 how middle class is this forum?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

PK99

Legendary Member
Location
SW19
I do socialise with a broad range of people, yes. And I have a broad range of cultural interests.

However, that is a lot less to do with my class than it is to do with me as a person, and it would still be true if I lived in a two up two down terrace in Liverpool 4 (indeed, it was, when I did)

You are missing the point - modern class is far less to do with roots as it is the boxes you tick as descriptors of current lifestyle. From your self description you tick all the boxes for Established middle class - I suspect that is a bridling against the term Middle Class given your background.

A quick google tells me that L4 now has a higher AB% (equivalent to Upper middle and middle class) than the national average. 31% vs 27%

Get over it. I'm from solid working class roots - Mum a mill girl then canteen hand, Dad a Cobbler then Labourer at Leyland Motors. I remember and respect my roots, but there is no way "Working class" would describe my lifestyle - despite having spent the 20 years up to retirement as mostly a jobbing gardener.
 

Andrew_P

In between here and there
Is there a class system? Blue collar white collar?

Wonder what the phycology is behind wanting to pigeonhole all the time?

Clearly a widening gap in earnings etc. I just can of see that as class anymore.

As a kid it seemed more defined but not now.
 

Dec66

A gentlemanly pootler, these days
Location
West Wickham
Get over it. I'm from solid working class roots - Mum a mill girl then canteen hand, Dad a Cobbler then Labourer at Leyland Motors. I remember and respect my roots, but there is no way "Working class" would describe my lifestyle - despite having spent the 20 years up to retirement as mostly a jobbing gardener.

Get over what? I'm not saying that being middle class is a bad thing, I just don't identify as such.

Also; I wouldn't rely on Google to tell you what Liverpool 4 is like. Honestly.
 

slowmotion

Quite dreadful
Location
lost somewhere
I wish I hadn't clicked on that.
When I clicked on that link, I got a message "Cannot reach this page".

I guess that means I'm total fubared for all Eternity.
 

ADarkDraconis

Cardinal Member
Location
Ohio, USA
[QUOTE 5194219, member: 43827"]Lidl! If you want to go up in the world you have to go to Aldi. Even if you're impecunious middle class you have to pretend you're classier than others.[/QUOTE]
I am still astounded by this because Aldi here in the States is generally a poorer grocery store, a discount shop with dented tins and discontinued goods amd somewhat questionable produce.
 

ADarkDraconis

Cardinal Member
Location
Ohio, USA
All that means is that you don’t agree with their definition of established middle class, not that the classification is wrong.
Or it means that it described you as established middle class with a definition of criteria and you do not meet one or more of those, so by its very definition it eliminates you from being it. It said I was the very same, and that it is the second richest class. By that defining point I am definitely out as we are a one-income family on a modest budget and are considered lower income here; we spend wisely while living within our means. I may have an education, manners, and 'classy' hobbies or acquaintances so it tossed me in there but money-wise I certainly do not fit that bill.

I had a play with the survey. The thing that seems to determine your class the most appears to be your income, property and savings unlike @nickyboy's view that it is mostly your upbringing.
I come out as established middle class which, I expect, is how others probably see me despite my working class upbringing. If I answer it as my 22 year old son, he comes out as emergent service worker due to his age, low wage and lack of property despite his more middle class upbringing.
It's all very silly.
I came out as 'Established Middle Class' with a low-ish income, no savings, and a very inexpensive house. But I do like classical music and enjoy going to the theatre (hey, Rocky Horror counts, right? :okay:)...
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom