Fun with Grammar.

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
OP
OP
M

MichaelM

Guru
Location
Tayside
But after Yello's post I'm not so sure.

In an essay, I wrote:

"I have demonstrated the growth in my own professional practice over the the course of the placement."

I should have used "development" instead !
 

yello

back and brave
Location
France
It's what I do. If in doubt, reword! :laugh:
 

fatblokish

Guru
Location
In bath
For some reason I find it very easy to use advice/advise correctly, yet practice/practise seems much harder to get right. Dunno why, despite the common ce/se endings.
 

Arch

Married to Night Train
Location
Salford, UK
There was no doubt - until it was marked as being incorrect!

I think you were correct. Their, his, my, all refer to a thing, owned by a person. That may be a physical thing (dog, hat), or a concept (skill, soul), but it's a thing, and therefore a noun. You cannot own a verb.

Here's my hobbyhorse: When a reporter on the telly is talking about something rare and describes it as 'one of the only ..... left in the country'. 'The Only' is a singular item in that context. You cannot have one of the only. You can have 'one of the few', or even 'one of only a few' (where only is.. well I dunno, an adjective?), but not 'one of the only'.
 

Maz

Guru
I agree it should be practice (noun) and not practise (at least in British English, anyway).

My pet peeve is the supermarket check-out signs saying 'Ten Items Or Less'. I heard somewhere that some supermarkets were going to adopt 'Up to 10 Items' instead.
 

subaqua

What’s the point
Location
Leytonstone
I think you were correct. Their, his, my, all refer to a thing, owned by a person. That may be a physical thing (dog, hat), or a concept (skill, soul), but it's a thing, and therefore a noun. You cannot own a verb.

Here's my hobbyhorse: When a reporter on the telly is talking about something rare and describes it as 'one of the only ..... left in the country'. 'The Only' is a singular item in that context. You cannot have one of the only. You can have 'one of the few', or even 'one of only a few' (where only is.. well I dunno, an adjective?), but not 'one of the only'.

it wouldn't be so bad if they said "one of only (x)" , where (x) is a number low enough to make sense in the context
 

Arch

Married to Night Train
Location
Salford, UK
it wouldn't be so bad if they said "one of only (x)" , where (x) is a number low enough to make sense in the context


Indeed, that would be fine, like I said, it's ok to say 'one of only a few'. It's the use of 'the' and 'only' together that rankles.
 
Top Bottom