Giving up Radio 4

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

CotterPin

Senior Member
Location
London
I must begin by acknowledging that I am very irregular poster in this corner of CycleChat - I hope you don't mind me joining your conversation.

After years of waking up to the Today prog and then getting home to hear Analysis, and similar programmes on R4, I finally snapped last week. It suddenly occurred to me that I was being fed relentless gloom and doom and "someone must be blamed" almost everyday. The tone of the programming appeared to be one long whinge. The government should be doing this. The police aren't policing; the government aren't governing; councils aren't ... errr... councilling. Big business is big business. It's always someone else's fault.

So one evening, in the middle of a programme about how some local council had failed its residents, I reached up and retuned to Radio 3.

Suddenly my day is full of Bach(s), Vivaldi, Shostokovich, and yet more strange, exotic and unfamiliar composers and performers. It is populated by an erudite and slightly eccentric group of people who seem to be forever apologising because the last programme has just over-run. And the news bulletins are a gentle whisper that I can barely hear and that are soon replaced by a little gem the presenter has found in his CD collection and wants to share with us.

It's not that I am opposed to Radio 4 programming. Indeed I still return to Radio 4 for (some of) the funnies and plays. It was just the sheer wall-to-wallness of gloom that got to me. To avoid getting caught I usually tune tentatively to R4 ready to tune away again in case I inadvertently get hit by another dose of whinging.

Now I feel more calm and relaxed when I arise (although late for work more often than in the past). And when I get home in the evening I can throw off the shackles of the working day more easily. If only I had done it sooner.

Now all I have to do is ween myself off P+L. :eek:
 

tdr1nka

Taking the biscuit
M8 I hear you.
John Humpries & Co. have put me in a dudgeon every morning this week.
It's been like waking up to Linford & Mr. Paul having a set to.

I find I only listen at certain times of day now.:eek:
 

MajorMantra

Well-Known Member
Location
Edinburgh
I think you should send this post to Feedback.

Lately I've barely heard any live radio 4 - I mostly listen to comedy and other odds and ends on the iplayer - much more rewarding.

Matthew
 
I used to love Radio 4, but like the OP, I'm avoiding the mainstream news there and on tv for that matter at the moment - it's all politics, mud-slinging, blame-assigning, gloomy-future stuff. To be honest, I can do without it! The main news and current affairs I go for nowadays are the Google subdivisions - in other words, I skim the headlines, read what interests me and avoid the stuff that I know is going to be depressing.

Classic FM is quite an antidote, I find. Not everyone's cup of tea, but enjoyable.
 

HelenD123

Legendary Member
Location
York
tdr1nka said:
M8 I hear you.
John Humpries & Co. have put me in a dudgeon every morning this week.
It's been like waking up to Linford & Mr. Paul having a set to.

I find I only listen at certain times of day now.:eek:

That's what made me stop listening a few years ago. I couldn't stand listening to the them debate/argue with people every morning. It was to depressing. I've started listening occasionally again though.
 

Fnaar

Smutmaster General
Location
Thumberland
The relentless badgering of 'guests' and quoting at them stuff they said 2 or 3 years ago under different circumstances is really bad journalism, imho. I'm all for questioning politicians and others in responsible positions, but do it fairly, without malice and all the rest of it. I can't listen to them any more either... :eek:
 
I hear you too. I listened to "Today" for 25 years starting in the days of Timpson and Redhead. When Humphrys took it on I stopped enjoying it but persevered as I could find little alternative source of in depth news and analysis. When Naughtie arrived on the scene he seemed to take his lead from Humphrys and most interviews by either of them turned into irritable, charmless exchanges with otherwise interesting guests.

I found myself getting wound up by the verbal baiting and adversarial antics of those two and eventually stopped listening in 2006. My life is no less rich, except I still miss Sue MacGregor. :eek:
 
I listen to occasional Radio 4 stuff, however...
Radio 5 live is of very good quality reporting, discussion and info-tainment kind of stuff. It's sport on the weekends, but I don't usually bother then.
The 5 live news seems to be told with a certain amount of humour, unless humour would not be appropriate.
So maybe give it a whirl. It's on MW instead of FM, but that's no biggy.
Any other regulars to this station?
 

Noodley

Guest
CotterPin said:
I must begin by acknowledging that I am very irregular poster in this corner of CycleChat - I hope you don't mind me joining your conversation.

Always good to see someone having given some thought to the area of the forum in which posts should go rather than just slotting them into areas of familiarity :ohmy:
 

rich p

ridiculous old lush
Location
Brighton
threebikesmcginty said:
I find Evan Davis and Eddie Mair unlistenable too - dreadful!

Eddie Mair is dreadful. Flippant, querulous and he lays traps for the unwary. I reach for the off button asap.

On the other hand, I listened to From Our Own Correspondent today and it is generally radio journalism of the highest order. They are interesting, important stories from around the globe that would never make it into any other programme bar the World Service. A piece on France and the traffic police today by the excellent John Laurenson is well worth a listen for the content, language and delivery.
 

rh100

Well-Known Member
I enjoyed Radio 4 for quite some time after tuning in to it after getting fed up of listening to the drivel Radio 2 had become, especially after Johnny Walker gave up the evening spot. I enjoyed listening to the documentaries and plays, especially when on night call out in the car. However, you're right it can get depressing sometimes and some it just plain doesn't interest me. Don't get to listen much now, even less now I commute by bike.

The documentaries are first class though, you don't get that anywhere else. There's even one on next week about War Of The Worlds type albums. However, the 'comedy' is a bit cringeworthy in places.
 

Rob S

New Member
Location
Plymouth
Talksport anyone!!?? :cry:

But seriously, I'm a Radio 5 Live man, Christ knows what I'll do when Simon Mayo goes to Radio 2 in January....he seems to be filling in for Chris Evans again this week and next :sad: I just hope Fi Glover will come back.
 
Top Bottom