Yes, 5'10 long arms and legs. Men's bikes, women's saddle always. Women's frames don't come big enough. Large Spesh hybrid, 54.5cm frame on the roadbike (which was built for me, in terms of bar width, stem length etc)
Best to get a proper fit and test ride - nothing worse than a bike that is too big
Sorry to bring up such an old topic. Just noticed you are as tall as me and I was just looking at the women models, but can't see anything bigger then 56cm which I am afraid might not fit me as I am 5'10 as well (178cm). Is there any point of trying any women bikes. Or should I just get mens bike and if so will there be any parts that I have to swap? I think the more I am looking into the bikes the more I am getting discouraged that I will ever be able to choose one.