Pedestrian victims

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

PK99

Legendary Member
Location
SW19
Victims of cycling collisions
The Telegraph has highlighted the numerous cases where pedestrians have died or been seriously injured as a result of collisions with cyclists. It has also exposed the many failings in the way such collisions are treated in law and by the police, as well as recorded on official Government data.

Hilda Griffiths

Hilda Griffiths, 81, died after she was struck by Brian Fitzgerald, a city banker and club cyclist, who was part of a high-speed peloton travelling at up to 29mph in Regent’s Park where a 20mph speed limit is in place. Her son, Gerard, has campaigned for a change in the law.

She was crossing the road on the junction of the Outer Circle and Hanover Terrace on Saturday June 25, 2022. She died more than 50 days after the collision.

Mrs Griffiths’ inquest heard that cyclists are not legally required to obey speed limits. As a result, Mr Fitzgerald, who works for Credit Suisse, could not be prosecuted.

Diana Walker

Diana Walker, 76, died when a cyclist hit her in Pewsey, Wiltshire, in April 2016. Her husband, Peter Walker, 85, has also campaigned for a law change.

He told The Telegraph: “All we are asking is that if a cyclist causes a pedestrian’s death it should be treated in the same way as any other road accident with commensurate legislation.”

Kim Briggs

Kim Briggs, 44, was killed after Charlie Alliston, then 20, hit her as she crossed Old Street, East London while riding a fixed-gear bike with no front brake. Ms Briggs, a mother of two, who was on her lunch break, suffered “catastrophic” head injuries and died in hospital a week later.

Mrs Briggs’s husband, Matt, 54, has campaigned tirelessly on securing updated laws to try to deter dangerous cycling.

Alliston, who was cleared of manslaughter, was jailed for 18 months for causing bodily harm by “wanton and furious” riding.

Jim Blackwood

Jim Blackwood, 91, was hit by an e-bike being ridden on the pavement in Kent in 2023. The Army veteran was putting his bins outside his home in Rochester when a man riding an e-bike collided with him.

His daughter, Christine White, 65, has called for tougher laws to target cyclists who flout road rules.

Peter McCombie

Peter McCombie, 72, died after being hit by cyclist Ermir Loka, 23, who jumped a red light in London in July 2020.

Loka was jailed for two years. Mr McCombie’s sister, Christine Berridge, told The Telegraph: “How many more people will need to die before ministers change the law?”

Paola Dos Santos
Paola Dos Santos was left seriously injured by a cyclist riding on the wrong side of the road at the exact same location where Mrs Griffiths was hit in Regent’s Park.

Polly Friedhoff
Polly Friedhoff, 81, was killed after colliding with a cyclist as she walked along a canal towpath in Oxfordshire in 2022.

Ms Friedhoff, who retired from her job as St Antony’s College’s first public relations and development officer in the mid-2000s, died in hospital 12 days after being hit.

Edward Bressan, 56, was cleared of cycling “wanton or furiously” on his B’Twin bicycle. He told Oxford Crown Court he was travelling at 3mph.

Her family said her death arose from “an ungoverned shared space which she herself had warned about”.

Jane Stone
Jane Stone, 79, died after being hit by a cyclist riding on the pavement in Monmouth, South Wales in 2021Stewart McGinn, 30, was jailed for a year after it emerged his bike had only one working brake and was travelling at speed.

John Douglas
John Douglas, 75, suffered 15 broken ribs and two broken collarbones after being hit by an e-bike ridden on the pavement near his Birmingham home in 2024. He was taken to hospital with injuries that included 15 broken ribs, two broken collarbones and a broken ankle. After four weeks in an induced coma and a few weeks in intensive care he developed pneumonia and died on New Year’s Day.

Christopher Bushell, Mr Douglas’s nephew, said he was dismayed by how the Government promotes cycling, e-bikes and e-scooters but has failed to keep laws up to date.

Ian Gunn
Ian Gunn, 56, died in June 2020 in south Manchester, and the cyclist was cleared of wanton and furious driving. Cornelius De Bruin was cleared of causing bodily harm to Mr Gunn in 2022. The cyclist was wearing headphones when he hit Mr Gunn.
 

fossyant

Ride It Like You Stole It!
Location
South Manchester
I bet you can fill that amount of text, in one afternoon, of deaths from motor vehicles - there is a few years worth of deaths in that article.
 
We all know that there are some riders that ride their machines in ways that cause rpoblems for the rest of us

and riding in such a way just encourages certin types fo media to demonise all cyclists

and, as usual, the use of the term "ebikes" to cover anything with 2 wheel, motor and a saddle (i.e. not a scooter)
whereas that goes from legal PEDALEC/EPAC type machine right up to machine that could match a motorbike with a 500cc engine or more

I would support a legal change making it illegal to ride recklessly - except that I think there are several already
and riding a electrically powered bike that is not a legal EPAC is already illegal in several ways anyway

I do sympathise with the victims - all of them
but it is enforcement that is needed - not more laws

although some tuning might help
 

Ian H

Ancient randonneur
...cyclists are not legally required to obey speed limits. As a result, Mr Fitzgerald, who works for Credit Suisse, could not be prosecuted.

Only because the police are to lazy/idle/overworked to prosecute for dangerous/careless cycling.
 

Dogtrousers

Lefty tighty. Get it righty.
10 cases. 5 prosecutions. 3 found guilty with sentences varying from 1 to 2 years.

Now, I'd be interested in knowing how that prosecution/ conviction / sentence rate stacks up against other modes of transport.

That's not to say that the law couldn't be improved. "Wanton and furious cycling" does sound a bit archaic. But you can't argue that the law needs to be changed to enable prosecution when 50% of the cases cited resulted in prosecution.

One thing I will say is that there will be very little sampling bias, because pretty much all of the cases are represented: 8 of the 10 cases occurred in the period 2019-2023. That makes two thirds of the total cases in this period (12 according to @Ian H 's link)

Did I say no sampling bias? Maybe I was mistaken. The other two were from 2016 and 2017, courtesy of the DT's cherry picking dept.
 

Punkawallah

Veteran
About 450 prosecutions for Causing Death by Dangerous Driving in 2018, 150 convictions, with sentences of 3-5 years. I picked 2018 because it was pre pandemic.
 

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Location
Inside my skull
Any death or serious injury is a tragedy.

Interesting use of the word numerous, the Telegraph's list spans 2016 - 2024 (ie 9 years), and 10 instances. 10 too many of course, but, numerous, I think not.

Approx 600,000 death or serious injuries caused to pedestrians by car drivers in same period. I wonder how many of them were prosecuted and if the DT is interested.
 
Victims of cycling collisions
The Telegraph has highlighted the numerous cases where pedestrians have died or been seriously injured as a result of collisions with cyclists. It has also exposed the many failings in the way such collisions are treated in law and by the police, as well as recorded on official Government data.

Hilda Griffiths

Hilda Griffiths, 81, died after she was struck by Brian Fitzgerald, a city banker and club cyclist, who was part of a high-speed peloton travelling at up to 29mph in Regent’s Park where a 20mph speed limit is in place. Her son, Gerard, has campaigned for a change in the law.

She was crossing the road on the junction of the Outer Circle and Hanover Terrace on Saturday June 25, 2022. She died more than 50 days after the collision.

Mrs Griffiths’ inquest heard that cyclists are not legally required to obey speed limits. As a result, Mr Fitzgerald, who works for Credit Suisse, could not be prosecuted.

Diana Walker

Diana Walker, 76, died when a cyclist hit her in Pewsey, Wiltshire, in April 2016. Her husband, Peter Walker, 85, has also campaigned for a law change.

He told The Telegraph: “All we are asking is that if a cyclist causes a pedestrian’s death it should be treated in the same way as any other road accident with commensurate legislation.”

Kim Briggs

Kim Briggs, 44, was killed after Charlie Alliston, then 20, hit her as she crossed Old Street, East London while riding a fixed-gear bike with no front brake. Ms Briggs, a mother of two, who was on her lunch break, suffered “catastrophic” head injuries and died in hospital a week later.

Mrs Briggs’s husband, Matt, 54, has campaigned tirelessly on securing updated laws to try to deter dangerous cycling.

Alliston, who was cleared of manslaughter, was jailed for 18 months for causing bodily harm by “wanton and furious” riding.

Jim Blackwood

Jim Blackwood, 91, was hit by an e-bike being ridden on the pavement in Kent in 2023. The Army veteran was putting his bins outside his home in Rochester when a man riding an e-bike collided with him.

His daughter, Christine White, 65, has called for tougher laws to target cyclists who flout road rules.

Peter McCombie

Peter McCombie, 72, died after being hit by cyclist Ermir Loka, 23, who jumped a red light in London in July 2020.

Loka was jailed for two years. Mr McCombie’s sister, Christine Berridge, told The Telegraph: “How many more people will need to die before ministers change the law?”

Paola Dos Santos
Paola Dos Santos was left seriously injured by a cyclist riding on the wrong side of the road at the exact same location where Mrs Griffiths was hit in Regent’s Park.

Polly Friedhoff
Polly Friedhoff, 81, was killed after colliding with a cyclist as she walked along a canal towpath in Oxfordshire in 2022.

Ms Friedhoff, who retired from her job as St Antony’s College’s first public relations and development officer in the mid-2000s, died in hospital 12 days after being hit.

Edward Bressan, 56, was cleared of cycling “wanton or furiously” on his B’Twin bicycle. He told Oxford Crown Court he was travelling at 3mph.

Her family said her death arose from “an ungoverned shared space which she herself had warned about”.

Jane Stone
Jane Stone, 79, died after being hit by a cyclist riding on the pavement in Monmouth, South Wales in 2021Stewart McGinn, 30, was jailed for a year after it emerged his bike had only one working brake and was travelling at speed.

John Douglas
John Douglas, 75, suffered 15 broken ribs and two broken collarbones after being hit by an e-bike ridden on the pavement near his Birmingham home in 2024. He was taken to hospital with injuries that included 15 broken ribs, two broken collarbones and a broken ankle. After four weeks in an induced coma and a few weeks in intensive care he developed pneumonia and died on New Year’s Day.

Christopher Bushell, Mr Douglas’s nephew, said he was dismayed by how the Government promotes cycling, e-bikes and e-scooters but has failed to keep laws up to date.

Ian Gunn
Ian Gunn, 56, died in June 2020 in south Manchester, and the cyclist was cleared of wanton and furious driving. Cornelius De Bruin was cleared of causing bodily harm to Mr Gunn in 2022. The cyclist was wearing headphones when he hit Mr Gunn.

All very tragic - but it's about one death per year.

Now tell me how many people motor vehicles killed over that same time period ?
 

Dogtrousers

Lefty tighty. Get it righty.
Take 2022 because I happen to have the figures in front of me
Total road fatalities: 1,695 (ref 1)
Total prosecutions for motoring offences resulting in death 340 (ref 2)

= 340/1,695 about 0.2 prosecutions per death.
Custody rate of 60% (ref 2)

The figures for cycling are harder to come by because the numbers are so much smaller to the point of being statistically useless. So instead of 2022 figures, I'll use the Telegraph's own curated data set. (Note: This is likely to have been cherry picked to support their argument that dangerous cyclists are not prosecuted) 10 deaths, 5 prosecutions. 3 jail terms.

= 5/10 or about 0.5 prosecutions per death.
Custody rate 3/5 = 60%

So a killer motorist is over twice as likely to get away scot-free as a killer cyclist, according to the above admittedly rushed, slapdash and hand-wavy analysis.

Ref 1 https://www.gov.uk/government/stati...alties-great-britain-provisional-results-2022
In reported road collisions in Great Britain in 2022 there were an estimated:
1,695 fatalities,


Ref 2 https://www.gov.uk/government/stati...stics-quarterly-december-2022-html#motoring12
Prosecutions for motoring offences which caused death declined by 19% in the latest year, from 419 in 2021 to 340 in 2022. The custody rate for these offences fluctuated between 55% and 67% over the last 5 years and was 60% in 2022
 
Last edited:

a.twiddler

Veteran
Hmm. I'm sure that someone put forward some figures for deaths and injuries from falling off furniture vs cycling related injuries on another forum a long time ago and they far outweighed the cycling figures.
 

Animo

Senior Member
I expect that a fair few cyclists every year are injured as a result of pedestrians walking out in front of them while looking at their phones or otherwise distracted.
 
Top Bottom