Sin bin for red light jumping cyclists

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

classic33

Leg End Member
But that's not what's on the other hand, is it? Currently, the other hand is offering a ridiculous argument that even though we don't illegally jump reds ourselves, we should still be fine with police prioritising cracking down on less-lethal less-damaging offenders just because they use the same vehicle type as us.

No. Just no. Police should prioritise those killing, injuring and damaging the most. Criminal motorists. Giving in to an irrational baying tabloid mob is not good policing.
I'd settle for the police going after those that are seen to break the law in front of them.
But would their powers to stop people they see breaking the law be good enough.
 

classic33

Leg End Member
Exactly
it is rather like shoplifters complaining that the cops should be going after the rapists


there have been numerous cases where "The Authorities" have started to crack down on the little things
and the effect has been to cut the big things as well
The one I heard all the time was "why aren't you out catching real criminals?. They never saw themselves as doing anything illegal whilst shoplifting.
 
Location
Widnes
The problem with priorities is that it gives the impression tha the little things are OK because no-one is enforcing it

so give up doing anything about red light jumping cyclists
and concentrate on putting a big effort into e.g. speeding motorists
then you get a lot of people thinking they are fine jumping red lights on bike because the cops will not do anything

Then "everyone" gets annoyed that every cyclist jumps red lights

and eventually
a) cars start doing it
b) someone will get killed/badly injured due to either jumping a red light when a car was coming - or a car swerves and looses control and hit a bus stop - or whatever

there needs to be a balance - but "The AUthorities" need to tackle everything somehow
 

mjr

Comfy armchair to one person & a plank to the next
There can be more than one priority at a time. The term does not have to be an absolute.
Oh for sure, but I ask again, when did the Met police last have a publicised crackdown catching red-light-jumping motorists and sitting them in a sin bin lecture? Or even just one where they only caught them all, even if it was just to give warnings?

It looks like the less-harmful is a priority but the more-harmful isn't.
 
Oh for sure, but I ask again, when did the Met police last have a publicised crackdown catching red-light-jumping motorists and sitting them in a sin bin lecture? Or even just one where they only caught them all, even if it was just to give warnings?

It looks like the less-harmful is a priority but the more-harmful isn't.

How long was that cyclist crackdown for, and how widespread was it? I thought it was only over the financial Square Mile area. Are police on patrol told only to stop cyclists running red lights or do they stop motorists as well if they see them on these patrols?

This is a one-off publicity campaign rather than a change of priorities.
 
but even just at pedestrian crossings, so theres none of that "its safer to do it" horcrux some cyclists peddle...I was up by Islington crossing the road on a light contolled crossing and you were just dodging people on bikes coming through, none of them were stopping.
Just to counter-balance that, I stopped at a red light in Islington this morning, and a Lime-bike rider stopped alongside me. Next thing we knew, a driver on the cross-wise road had decided that he couldn't wait for his exit to be clear so that he could turn right, and was coming straight at us on the wrong side of the road, through the lights. He was quite cross that we didn't subserviently and instantly leap out of his way.

Might have been safer to jump the lights and get out of the way before he got there :unsure:
 
Location
Widnes
a) Erm car drivers already do it!

b) those drivers are already hitting and killing daily.

Yes - but as far as I can see it is rare


at least rare to the impression people give of it happening in London

but then again - I seldom got to London so I could be wrong

but again - stopping bikes doing it - means you are in place to stop cars as well
and cars are easier to stop than bikes as they can't just nip down an alley or whatever
 

katiewlx

Über Member
Yes - but as far as I can see it is rare


at least rare to the impression people give of it happening in London

but then again - I seldom got to London so I could be wrong

but again - stopping bikes doing it - means you are in place to stop cars as well
and cars are easier to stop than bikes as they can't just nip down an alley or whatever

the difference in most parts of London and so its rarer for car drivers now to jump red lights, though absolutely it still happens, is because there are enough traffic cameras around, and councils with the desire to use them and to issue fines, that drivers learn at least what happens if they dont stop for a red light.

this is why I think this issue is something that needs to be solved before the inevitable conclusion is drawn by those that end up elected with a desire to do anything just to be seen to do something, that the way to stop cyclists jumping red lights is via registration that makes them identifiable to the same cameras.
 

Bristolian

Über Member
Location
Bristol, UK
And he'd be quite right.

On the other hand, how can we expect another sector of society to abide by certain behavioral standards if we choose not to do so ourselves? We can't justify offending because a type offending that happens to be convenient to us is less harmful - it's still offending. We don't listen to that guff from other classes of offender, so why should we be a special case just because it happens to be us doing it?

Like speeding motorists whinging, if everyone behaved for even a few weeks the cameras and vans would soon disappear. If we as a user group at large behaved the authorities would soon clear off elsewhere, and motoring offenders would have one less excuse to not alter their own ways.

Like it or not, complaining won't change anything. Only taking a genuine moral high ground with a suitable behavioural example will change anything, be that for us or motorists.
I absolutely agree with this 💯 percent :okay:
 

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Photo Winner
Location
Inside my skull
Yes - but as far as I can see it is rare

It is not captured in stats, and we cannot rely on anecdote or statistically invalid observations to decide if something is rare.

What do know from what is reported, and the introduction of red light cameras, is the drivers running red lights causes enough accidents to be a problem.

If it was rare, there would have been no need to introduce red light cameras. A process that continues to this day.

Watching non red light camera traffic lights is illuminating. As is watching drivers enter the advanced cyclist box when the light is amber or already on red. I won’t give any numbers as it is just more anecdote.

Just remember red light cameras exist (as do traffic lights) because of drivers of motorised vehicles.
 
Top Bottom