The Cranston R9 Brompton knockoff...

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

wafter

I like steel bikes and I cannot lie..
Location
Oxford
Spotted here on ebay for £600 new...

On cursory inspection this appears to be a blatant Brompton knockoff with a few differences; the most obvious being a 1x9 drivetrain as opposed to the Brompton's weirdo hub and / or 4sp derailleur approach.

The gearing system may or may not be "better" - certainly more straightforward, possibly cheaper, probably lighter, maybe a bit close to the ground... not sure about axle spacing or wheel dish / strength).

The execution of the bike itself may or may not be comparable to the product that it's imitating, but to those who aren't going to dig too deep it looks like an easy sell at well under half the price of a "comparable" 4sp C-Line.

On top of that, while the Chinese have a deserved reputation for flagrantly copying other people's IP, I notice more recently they seem to be showing a lot of innovation and improvement as well. In this case one tiny little indication in this direction is the apparently metal protection plate on the rear triangle to protect the finish when folded. After years of this area getting rapidly ruined due to the pitiful half-arsed nod towards protection fitted by Brompton (a thin plastic patch that's chewed to nothing after a few weeks of use) it looks like the copycat has actually gone one better than the product it's ripping off.

This does make me wonder whether in a few years time we might actually see knock-offs that are both cheaper and objectively better than their "inspiration".

Not difficult to see why Brompton's struggling, is it?
 
Last edited:

Riverman

Guru
I don't buy it as aren't there anti-dumping tariffs on folding bike imports at the moment? Not many will be getting through.

It's odd too how these tariffs were removed for regular but not folding bikes.*

*Turns out the only folding bikes the tariffs apply to are electric ones.

To be honest I feel it's high time other companies be allowed to use Brompton's design.
 
Last edited:

steveindenmark

Legendary Member
I used to call them 'Brompton rip offs'. But then I found Brompton folding patent ran out in 1999. There are a few Asian companies now making bikes that resemble Bromptons. But they are adding things that Brompton should have been adding years ago. Proper gears and gear levers, disc brakes, wider tyres, paint that stays on the frame. Things that only Kinetics in Scotland could do.
 
OP
OP
wafter

wafter

I like steel bikes and I cannot lie..
Location
Oxford
I used to call them 'Brompton rip offs'. But then I found Brompton folding patent ran out in 1999. There are a few Asian companies now making bikes that resemble Bromptons. But they are adding things that Brompton should have been adding years ago. Proper gears and gear levers, disc brakes, wider tyres, paint that stays on the frame. Things that only Kinetics in Scotland could do.

Yup; all stuff that should have been included in the natural evolution of Brompton's products were they not asleep at the wheel.

Fair enough they have explored some of these improvements with the G-line, but that's too big for many of the use-cases filled by the 16" model and all those improvements would be just as welcome on the smaller one - fatter tyres for a more comfy ride on our terrible roads, hydro discs because they're just better, generally better quality is always welcome... we should also be seeing frame protection that actually works, decent full-coverage mudguards, some proper bloody hinges.

All seems like an opportunity lost on Brompton's part - domestic manufacture and "innovation" are the reasons oft-cited for choosing them over cheaper competitors; the latter is becoming more and more of a joke considering the copies are starting to get better than the originals.

If they'd made meaningful improvement I think they'd still be ahead of the pack; as it stands their justification for their price and position in the market seems less and less legitimate.

The counter I suppose is that they've done well to keep their head above water this long, considering the consequences of similar came home to roost for the UK car manufacturing 40-50 years ago.
 

Drago

Legendary Member
Location
The Urban Fringe
Brompton have been extracting the proverbial with price since they were formed and still manage to stagger from crisis to crisis, punctuated with the occasional relatively profitable spell, so theres clearly something fundamentally amiss with the business model. The only real surprise is that it's taken the vultures this long to start circling.
 

Jameshow

Guru
Brompton have been extracting the proverbial with price since they were formed and still manage to stagger from crisis to crisis, punctuated with the occasional relatively profitable spell, so theres clearly something fundamentally amiss with the business model. The only real surprise is that it's taken the vultures this long to start circling.

Perhaps they are a private company with an owner with deep pockets....
 

Drago

Legendary Member
Location
The Urban Fringe
Being run as a hobby rather than a consistently serious attempt to make money would explain a lot.

Ot would also explain the lack of ongoing development and why, for what they charge, they arent far and away the best folding bicycles in christemdom.
 
Top Bottom