The rollercoaster of cycling popularity

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Badger_Boom

Veteran
Location
York
Oddly, I realise that I think kinda the opposite. Someone who considers their bike as simply a mode of transport isn't a cyclist. That is, I don't think they would see themselves as one. I think they'd consider 'them over there, in all the gear', to be cyclists but not themselves. They're just some who rides a bike. I see it as a kind of identity thing.

But, I mean, obviously they're both cyclists. Jeez, anyone who rides a bike is a cyclist! It's semantics, and identity. I consider myself a cyclist but primarily because it occupies an important part of my life. It's how I identify (it's my pronoun?? not intending to make light btw) I do both - I wear the gear AND it's a mode of transport. By contrast, my car is definitely only a mode of transport. I'm not interested in cars otherwise and am not a 'petrol head', or whatever other label there is.

(I'm saying lots of 'kind of' because I know I'm being very clumsy!)

I think I understand what you mean. I tend to (probably itrrationally) classify people into two groups:

Cyclists - On the road or cycle lane, moving with purpose and look like they know what they're about
People on bikes - Often on the pavement and sometimes on and off it at a whim, ponderous, nervous looking.

Type of bike, clothing an dfother equipment seems to be irrelevant to what category they fall into.
 

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Photo Winner
Location
Inside my skull
Do ebikers identify as motor cyclists?
 

yello

back and brave
Location
France
Do ebikers identify as motor cyclists?

I went there, sort of, earlier. My last event, around 2 weekends ago now, was something organised by the tourist office. So it was family friendly, discover our beautiful region etc etc. Nothing too intense but there was a good mix of 'cyclists' of all persuasion. There was a helluva lot of ebikes too, predominantly ridden by the more elderly. Quite frankly, I was surprised by just how many ebikes there were, but that's another story. Anyways, I was thinking only this morning as to how ebikers saw themselves.

As a related addendum, as I flogged myself up a climb (I'm out of shape tbh but it was a decent climb nonetheless) and elderly lady on a sit-up-and-beg electric bike just sailed past me, not a care in the world. Made me want to give up.
 

Andy in Germany

Legendary Member
I think the motor vehicle lobby have become very adept at the old adage of "Accuse your opposition of what you intend to do".

For example, through lobbying they've practically forced people into using cars, by making sure infrastructure decisions and planning policies always favoured cars, like removing railway lines, and by fighting against anything that would even slightly hinder vehicles, like speed limits or preventing vehicles from entering town centres.

They've somehow managed to call this forced motorisation "Freedom of choice" and every time someone suggests an alternative, they howl loudly about "allowing people to choose" and "not forcing people to cycle (or use the train/bus, etc)".

I have to admit, that was very well played, and like a lot of propaganda, it doesn't matter if it's true, it matters that it was repeated, because over time the idea that cars are freedom and making alternatives more available was "forcing people" to use alternatives; when you see this idea filtering onto forums like this one, it shows how effective it has become.

The reality of the very well documented phenomenon of Induced Demand; that when you build more roads, you end up with more traffic is quietly ignored, as well as the observation that Induced Demand works both ways: as you build more space for cars, you make every other form of transport more difficult, from walking to cycling to public transport; but if you build alternative ways for people to transport themselves, in a city, you necessarily make driving more difficult and less attractive, but you also improve life for everyone else in the city who isn't driving. it's been observed for nearly half a century in half of Europe, that city centres without cars usually get more foot traffic, so business thrive there, neighbourhoods where through roads are blocked or traffic-calmed are more pleasant to live in and there are more interactions amongst residents and children become more independent, but of course, that's not fitting the script of the motoring lobby, so they promote the idea that "driving= freedom", even though really the opposite is true in many ways.

The next carefully created reversal is the idea that making space for cars is "investment" and public transport is "Subsidised", to try and hide the point that we all pay for roads directly and indirectly, subsidising car use. The most egregious example of this to me is street parking, where large parts of public roads are used for private storage, for free, but there are many more examples, like damage to buildings, infrastructure and public health caused by motor transport. These are borne bay society, which is carefully ignored by the motor vehicle lobby, to avoid admitting that for some people to have the "freedom of choice", a lot of people are paying the bill.

After locking people into this system, where you have to pay for the infrastructure for cars whether you use it or not, and also own and maintain very expensive equipment to use the infrastructure available most effectively, the final big reversal is one that I've had thrown at me more and more in recent years: that people who don't oven a car are somehow "privileged" and we can't expect everyone to do it. This is in fact two untruths: one being being the idea thatmaking it difficult not to use a car if "freedom" but sugesting alternatives is "forcing people" There is also the inbuilt contradiction in these two arguments, of course: if "Driving is Freedom", then how am I "privileged" if I opt out?

After 25 years of car-free living I've found the "freedom of choice" presented, is hollow, a smoke screen intended to distract us from the fact that car dependency robs many people of freedom, as well as the other inconvenient facts the motor lobby would really rather we didn't look too carefully.
 

Andy in Germany

Legendary Member
... as I flogged myself up a climb (I'm out of shape tbh but it was a decent climb nonetheless) and elderly lady on a sit-up-and-beg electric bike just sailed past me, not a care in the world. Made me want to give up.

I don't know what the rules are in France, but here in Germany I am happy to let them pass me on the uphill, as I know I'll sail past them later as their motor cuts out at 25km/h.
 

Dogtrousers

Lefty tighty. Get it righty.
If you look at your usage, how you primarily get around. If you had to measure the hours over a year, what would the percentage breakdown look like?

I do a fair bit of cycling, it's true and I'm fairly sure I cycle more hours than I drive these days. But it's not my main form if transport . That's almost certainly the train.

In fact, given that when I cycle I always end up where I started, and never do anything other than cycling while I'm out, I'd question whether the bike is even a form of transport in my case. More just a leisure activity.

Yours, not-a-cyclist.

(I'm not knocking utility cycling btw. But it's not something I ever do)
 

SpokeyDokey

69, & my GP says I will officially be old at 70!
Moderator
Excluding members on CC, I only know 9 cyclists who ride regularly. 4 are high-mileage hard-core.

Not one uses their bike(s) as an all-purpose utility machine. All cycle for fun (masochists!)

Not one hankers for a bike-centric world. 3 are serious petrol-heads. The rest also have cars that are their primary transport tool.

My point being, admittedly based on a small sample, is that the anti-car pro-bike lobby is a very small % of all cycle users, and that the dream of a major culture change in the UK is a non-starter, imo.
 

Dogtrousers

Lefty tighty. Get it righty.
True with a car as well.

Not if you do something in the meantime - work, shopping etc. I'd class that as transport - going to a place for some purpose, and the maybe returning. That's unlike my cycling, when I never do anything other than cycling (and the odd brief coffee stop) when I'm out.

So if I'm not a cyclist I guess I'm something else. An Idle Wheeler maybe.
 

All uphill

Still rolling along
Location
Somerset
While we are sharing our personal perceptions of other people's views.

Everybody I know comes back from holiday saying how much they enjoyed traffic free town centres, pavement cafes, pizzas in piazzas, sunny promenades with roller skaters, cyclists, street entertainers,

and how much they'd hate it if anyone tried any of those things over here.
 
Location
Widnes
I don't know what the rules are in France, but here in Germany I am happy to let them pass me on the uphill, as I know I'll sail past them later as their motor cuts out at 25km/h.

I am quite happy for people to pass me on the flat if they can do it

It does annoy me when they simply come up behind and yell something just as they get level with my back wheel
i.e. no bells or warning of any kind

I have had a few that have passed and then not been able to maintain the speed so I have ended up having to slow down to let them get away

in a couple of cases I have ended up riding in "off" mode in order to avoid passing them!

but generally if they pass me then good on them and I am happy for them to pull away

but a proper legal ebike is not a motorbike - especially UK legal ones - other countries differ

illegal ones are different
 

scotsbikester

Über Member
While we are sharing our personal perceptions of other people's views.

Everybody I know comes back from holiday saying how much they enjoyed traffic free town centres, pavement cafes, pizzas in piazzas, sunny promenades with roller skaters, cyclists, street entertainers,

and how much they'd hate it if anyone tried any of those things over here.
Interesting. It seems that everybody you know has a holiday in another country.
 
Top Bottom