but car drivers have training and a licence but many still break the rules all the time, the police can already issue fines to cyclists for riding on pavements or jumping red lights; what difference would a licence make?
Well, the thing is that this just isn't true...and I'm not being facetious here.
If I break your post down, its clear that it would be impossible for drivers to " break the rules all of the time" if they did...literally ALL of the time... then the law of averages suggest they would get caught... some of the time.... and eventually loose their licence.
I think I know what you mean though, which is that having a licence doesn't automatically turn car drivers into
totally law abiding citizens. But it does, as @
Davidsw8 eludes, generate boundary's within which we can act and be seen to act.
Other road users see us cyclist as having no such boundary's and therefore as being totally lawless... that annoys them and marginalises us. The occasional stopping of the odd rider who jumps a red just doesn't register with them. This is a view that I cant help but sympathise with, I have to admit to seeing more law breaking from the cycle fraternity than from any other road users.... in town.
This isn't about the safety of others...its about OUR safety. I appreciate that 1000 cyclists can jump a red and no-one will get hurt, yet it only takes one car to follow suit and...well you can imagine. I would only be interested in making an agreement to behave by a set of rules, so that others can see that we are happy to do so (or pay the price)... not to try and save the life of a car driver that we may collide with if we jumped a red.
Having this agreement may lead to other road users treating us with more respect,This is the conflict that I think needs to be addressed. So anything that we could agree to that helps remove this conflict, will help move us from the gutter...so to speak
Personally I would wear a licence as a badge of honour, it would make me an elite rider, one who is trained and experienced enough to ride in some of the most congested parts of Britain, without conflict.
Its still impossible though, I know that.