Which groupset?

105 7000 or SRAM Rivel 22 or Tiagra 4700?

  • SRAM Rival 22

    Votes: 5 26.3%
  • Shimano 105 7000

    Votes: 11 57.9%
  • Tiagra 4700 10 speed?

    Votes: 3 15.8%

  • Total voters
    19
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Milzy

Legendary Member
Doing a cheap build up and these 3 can be bought brand new for around £300.
I’m wanting lighter and the SRAM is lighter of the 3 but the other two are bullet proof.
 

chriswoody

Legendary Member
Location
Northern Germany
What makes you say the SRAM is not bulletproof? I have the 1x version of the SRAM Rival drivetrain that is 10 years old and well over 20,000 km. I've never had any major issues with it.

The best bit about the Rival drivetrain over Shimano is that you can actually work on it. The shifters can be disassembled, cleaned and greased. Whilst SRAM themselves refuse to provide spares, companies like Ratio Technology manufacture some parts like replacement cable spools. Personally it's no question in my mind, SRAM over Shimano any day.
 

cyberknight

As long as I breathe, I attack.
tiagra 4700 is fine as long as you remember to change the cables regularly as they are prone to being shredded inside the shifter due to the cable routing .
i have sram 10 speed on my old alloy boardman thats still going strong after 14 years and i have rival 22 on the best bike .
 

Bristolian

Über Member
Location
Bristol, UK
I don't see me going for anything from SRAM as all my knowledge (such as it is) comes from Shimano use. I've had the same conversation with myself about Tiagra vs 105 and the latter always comes out on top. That may be a bit of subconscious bias ~ groupset of the public and all that ~ but I believe 105 is superior to Tiagra which, in turn, is superior to the Sora currently on my bike.
 
OP
OP
Milzy

Milzy

Legendary Member
I do have some nice hand builds with a 10 hub. You can use 11 and a spacer.
I’ve never owned SRAM and tried a mates years ago. I liked the shift method.
 

fritz katzenjammer

Der Ubergrosserbudgie
I’ve set up hundreds of these things and then serviced them later when they come in. They are all pretty much bullet proof and will shift reliably forever with a minimum of maintenance. I always found 105 the nicest to set up and the quietest in operation, I always felt that SRAM was a bit notchy feeling But like the 105, dead accurate and reliable. You really can’t go wrong with any of those you listed.

However, Keep in mind… when it came to building up my own bike around a new 2023 Trek Domane roadbike frame, with full access to all the goodies in the Trek, Shimano and SRAM catalogues at over 50% off, I used a 1972 Shimano Crane ( 1st gen Dura Ace! ) derailleur and friction shifters on 80s mountain bike bars, so maybe I can’t be trusted.
 
Last edited:

Drago

Legendary Member
Location
The Urban Fringe
I don't see me going for anything from SRAM as all my knowledge (such as it is) comes from Shimano use. I've had the same conversation with myself about Tiagra vs 105 and the latter always comes out on top. That may be a bit of subconscious bias ~ groupset of the public and all that ~ but I believe 105 is superior to Tiagra which, in turn, is superior to the Sora currently on my bike.
If my superior you mean a fraction lighter, a fraction prettier, and a extra cog you'd be right.

In terms of the efficiency and reliability of the change theres zip difference between my 2x Tiagra bikes and 2 x 105 bikes. They both snap instantly and positively onto the required cog, and both do so unfailingly.
 
OP
OP
Milzy

Milzy

Legendary Member
I rode a Scott hotel bike in Italy with Tiagra set up perfect. It was really nice and crisp. Didn’t feel like it was that heavy either really.
 

vickster

Squire
I'm a SRAM mechanical fan (have Rival 20/22 on all my bikes, rim and mech disc brakes), would never buy Shimano (other than to sell on and switch to SRAM). Don't like the wobbly Shimano brake lever and massive hoods and Double tap works perfectly well
Horses for courses though, Shimano is more popular
 
Last edited:

Webbo2

Veteran
I have always used Shimano however I was once loaned a SRAM equipped bike. I kept trying push the brake lever to change gear which clearly is wrong. I had the bike for 2 weeks but never got to grips with it. I’m sure that I would have eventually got it in the end but it didn’t seem natural.
 
OP
OP
Milzy

Milzy

Legendary Member
I'm a SRAM mechanical fan (have Rival 20/22 on all my bikes, rim and mech disc brakes), would never buy Shimano (other than to sell on and switch to SRAM). Don't like the wobbly Shimano brake lever and massive hoods and Double tap works perfectly well
Horses for courses though, Shimano is more popular

I didn’t know that. You’ve sold me, I have a Condor r7000 which is super smooth but I’m getting Rival to be different. Plus it will suit the Look frame.
 
OP
OP
Milzy

Milzy

Legendary Member
I have always used Shimano however I was once loaned a SRAM equipped bike. I kept trying push the brake lever to change gear which clearly is wrong. I had the bike for 2 weeks but never got to grips with it. I’m sure that I would have eventually got it in the end but it didn’t seem natural.

I switch between Campag and Shimano a lot so takes a few mins to get back dialled in.
SRAM just think little push big push. Love it.
 
Top Bottom