SavageHoutkop said:
I'm still pondering why car-sharing doesn't take off more. For instance, I'm completely car free but (very) occasionally need a car (moving large things; doing a tour of various out of the way places for sightseeing). I think I've hired a car 3x in 3 years now. If there are cars which are not used often, like Sheffield's and Debian's, it's not good for the car either and the standing costs (MOT, insurance) are very high for the mileage.
I've lived in London since 2001, haven't had a car since 2002. I have not hired a car (in the UK) since. When I sold my car, I expected I'd be hiring one occasionally, but in practice car hire, or joining a scheme like Streetcar, just proved unnecessary, or more expensive & more hassle than getting a cab to wheel me around.
By way of example: I hosted some relatives in London last October and thought of joining Streetcar so we could visit some interesting places, taking the car when needed. Until I discovered that getting minicabs would be cheaper, and naturally they came with a driver & hassle-free door-to-door trips, avoiding all the hassle of having the car yourself (risk of causing damage, parking trouble & fines, speeding tickets and so on).
The idea of car sharing schemes does have some appeal, but has stiff competition from other flexible options, including taxi services, other car & van rental companies, public transport, and car-owning friends who may be perfectly willing to offer you a lift if you "invite" them along to the same destination/event.