Being serious, I saw the beta in action a lot and I did like the performance of it. What ended up in the final layout is a bit strange but there you go. It'll evolve. I won't be buying it though.
Whatever you say about windows people will say the same things. Much of the time it depends on the timings of launch, length until replacements and computer advancements during that time. XP was not regarded as superduper reliable when it launched at all, that was a total myth. It acquired this status for the simple reason that the length between XP and Vista was so vast that it had various service packs and development and it coincided with very dramatic CPU advancements and a few other things. Vista was worse than XP but it got a lot of its reputation because imbeciles were putting it in machines there weren't really ideal to run it. Now some of that is microsoft's fault but some of it is the idiots that built these machines and packaged them deliberately knowing how bad they'd be.
Yeah, the reviews by people always tend to be polarised too an OS is either awesome or terrible, rarely inbetween and often gets decided by how well the early release goes and how resistant people are to change. My understanding is that the latter versions of Vista with its servicepacks were actually good, but like you say the early versions had compatibility issues compounded by it being installed as standard on budget machines that werent upto it - my friend bought an acer laptop with 500mb of ram and it was next to useless. Even the beloved XP was terrible when it was first launched, frequenty security problems and compatibility issues IME.
Im still unsure if i should upgrade to windows 8, it was inevitable it would be disliked after the popularity of win7. Theres been that trend of each OS alternating between awesome and terrible in peoples eyes arguably back to 3.1(1) > 95 > 98 > ME > XP > Vista > Win7 > Win 8. My understanding is that you dont have to use Metro, just stay in desktop mode and use the quicksearch in place of the start bar and your commonly used apps should be shortcut/pinned anyway. I think the issue is most people used win7 like they did XP, but should have been pinning apps, launching things from the search rather than trawling through programs, otherwise the jump away from a start bar wouldnt be so harsh. I might upgrade my XP machine and see how it goes
