Work Benches: some advice please

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
OP
OP
Speicher

Speicher

Vice Admiral
Moderator
I've been using a cheap one from ScrewFix for about 8 years now, cost me £6. (yes, six pound). It's still going average! (buy cheap doesn't always mean buy twice)

You could spend a lot more, but if it's just to hold the odd skirting board or chunk of 3x2 for sawing, they're fine. The vice isn't great... but they're not like a proper woodworking vice on a proper bench... folding workbenches are a compromise, no matter how much you pay.

I'm about 11.5 stone and also use it as platform to work from... if it's strong enough to stand on and work from, it's strong enough.

height wise, they about the same as a table, which is a little on the low side for me (6'2")... but it's the same height as my dads posh black and decker one.


:scratch: Does £6 in 2003 equate to about £24 now? If so that is the price of the basic Work Mate available at my local Ironmonger's shop*. I might start off with that,or the next one up is "dual height" which is £64.


* This shop is a modern version of the one in "Four Candles" and you can still buy one bolt or seven hinges, if that is what you require.
 

craven2354

Well-Known Member
:scratch: Does £6 in 2003 equate to about £24 now? If so that is the price of the basic Work Mate available at my local Ironmonger's shop*. I might start off with that,or the next one up is "dual height" which is £64.


* This shop is a modern version of the one in "Four Candles" and you can still buy one bolt or seven hinges, if that is what you require.
Can you buy four candles? ;)
 
I would have at least (if not more) a 75 x 75mm 'leg' of wood running from underside of worksurface to the floor. Then, if you need to whack something with passion, there is adequate support for the 'bash' - directly above this 'leg' - and not a noisy, vibrating worktop and sub-optimal effort. :smile:
 

MontyVeda

a short-tempered ill-controlled small-minded troll
:scratch: Does £6 in 2003 equate to about £24 now? If so that is the price of the basic Work Mate available at my local Ironmonger's shop*. I might start off with that,or the next one up is "dual height" which is £64.

I reckon... It equates to £20 at screw fix... I think this is more or less the same as what i've got.

Dual hight isn't worth the extra... for the amount of times you use the lower height, you may as well save your money and use a dining chair instead, which is about what the lower height is.
 
OP
OP
Speicher

Speicher

Vice Admiral
Moderator
I reckon... It equates to £20 at screw fix... I think this is more or less the same as what i've got.

Dual hight isn't worth the extra... for the amount of times you use the lower height, you may as well save your money and use a dining chair instead, which is about what the lower height is.

Thank you Monty. Screwfix charge £5 for next day delivery, rather than my having to get into the c*r.
I would rather buy at a local shop though.
 
Location
Rammy
I've had one of these for quite some time, it has proved to be very useful and has saved me from many skint knuckles.
http://www.blackanddecker.co.uk/powertools/productdetails/catno/WM536/

I have not bought any accessories but use the 'Swivel pegs' a lot. If anything else needs to be held securely then G cramps usually do the job.
The option of being able to adjust the height can be handy.
I have one of those, I did pay a little extra for it being black and decker based on my dad's being 30 years old and still going strong. The other reason being I had a cheap one where the top was made from MDF which fell apart within the year.
I don't like the cheaper ones that have a bar across where I find I place my feet when using it to saw (the black and decker's plate is in pretty much the ideal place to plonk my foot to brace the bench at either height setting
with regards to fitting a larger work surface, just get your surface, fix a ridge of wood on the underside and you'll be able to clamp it to the bench by closing it up.
 

Night Train

Maker of Things
From my experience there are good and bad 'Workmates'.

I have had and used one of the original types, very similar to the Clarke one below, and it has given some 30+ years of faultless service. It has long vice screws and the jaws are well located and don't move about when you don't want them to. very quick and easy to fold and unfold, I used to lift it up and 'flick it' to unfold before pressing the locks down. It would fold again as quickly when it was unlocked again. If you can get a good one of this type, with the A frame legs, I would recommend it as suitable for what you need it for. Add to it a couple of G cramps and maybe a couple of low cost sash cramps and it will do most tasks.

clarkebench.jpg


There are also the X frame leg workmates. I have never used one and so can't comment on whether they are better or worse then the A frame type.
8873703079966.jpg



I bought one of these multi-function ones thinking it would be an improvement. It wasn't. More then once I was 'bitten' by the folding legs at the bottom when folding or unfolding it to use. It was awkward to manage and heavy. Once, the top failed to lock and collapsed on me. The moving jaw has too little thread and so has very limited movement. The 'fixed' jaw is located with 'keyhole' slots for different positions to make up for the vice screws being too short. This set up is awkward as the screws are only just long enough for each of the 'fixed' jaw positions so you will constantly be adjusting the position of the fixed jaw.
Also, if you try to grip something small at one end of the vice, the other end will pop off the keyhole location when you start work. You have to add a block at the other end of the vice jaw of near the same size as the thing you are working on. There is also the option to lift up the vice jaw to clamp downwards. I have yet to find something that it can hold that still allows me to work on it. G cramps are better and more flexible for use. Do not get one of these.
41%2BW6-yCjbL._SL500_AA300_.jpg


I also have one of these for taking out in the car for small jobs.
It is good but doesn't have any means of keeping it still when working with it. I will need to screw it to a board that can then be clamped down onto a table when needed.
Notice that when it is on a flat surface, floor or table, you cannot turn the vice handles without lifting it up every turn. Awkward when there is nothing in it but very awkward when trying to hold some work in the vice at the time. Ok for some uses.
T2eC16VHJH8E9qSEWJ-KBP-dm0ul0g60_12.jpg
 
OP
OP
Speicher

Speicher

Vice Admiral
Moderator
Thank you everyone for your helpful comments. From what has been written on this thread, I think I will purchase a fairly basic Black and Decker A frame work mate, and some G clamps. My first task will be to attach a thick piece of wood to a much larger piece to make a stable work top. I am sure that the correct-sized pieces are already in the garage.

My second task will be to follow @asterix's example and make a hole in the wall of the above-mentionned garage, and support the floor above it with assorted planks, joists and very thick webbing. :unsure:^_^
 
Top Bottom