I like the Hugo Boss range of colognes. I've got 4 different ones and they're all quite subtle rather than the 'shouty' stuff favoured by many of less advanced years than me
Recently my young daughters spent some (though I am guessing not much!) of their pocket money on some after shave for my recent birthday from a market stall. I can't remember the name, but from the smell it shoudl have been Eau de cat urine, and the first time I used it (at their insistance) it had a similar effect on my skin to Nitromors.