My Aldi lobster gloves arrived today.
They actually DO have liners inside the 2-finger compartments so they feel like normal gloves while the fingers are alongside each other. As soon as you do the predictable Vulcan '
Live long and prosper' gesture, the lobster claw design becomes more obvious!
The gloves feel warm when worn inside the house and I suspect that they would keep my hands warm in any temperatures that I am likely to ride in, unless my hands got wet. I'm not sure how waterproof they will be. Hang on, I'll immerse my lobstered hands in a bowl of water and find out ...!
(Time passes ... slowly!)
Ok - The gloves did not let any water through to my fingers while holding my hands under water for one minute, but water WAS being absorbed. The gloves felt heavier, and when I took them off I could wring water out of them. I'm fairly sure that water WOULD get through eventually in heavy rain but I suspect that the gloves would then act like wetsuits for the hands. By keeping the wind off wet fingers, I think they could stay pretty warm.
The lobster design didn't feel too odd when holding the bars and operating the brake and gear levers.
I'll wear the gloves the next time I do a bad weather ride and see what they are like in actual use.