Exotic wheel lacing pattern.....how to work out the spoke length?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Ajax Bay

Legendary Member
Location
East Devon
I have a Campagnolo Ventum wheelset where the rear wheel has 24 spokes: spokes grouped in 3s, one non-drive side (NDS), two drive side (DS) in each set (x 8 obv). The DS are 2-cross and the NDS one is radial. [edited] DS can't be radial because that hub flange has torque to transmit.
I have not investigated but I suspect that this means that the spokes are all the same length and also means the spoke tension is similar (as opposed to 1000N DS and 1500N NDS).
I have had fun constructing this diagram, which is illustrative.
1794854048426.png

Key:
Red - radial NDS
Green - leading
Blue - trailing
I suspect the spoke holes on the flanges are not aligned DS - NDS but offset, to make the three spokes in each set parallel, with equal distance between the NDS and DS spokes (not quite as diagram).
 
Last edited:

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Photo Winner
Location
Inside my skull
I suspect that this means that the spokes are all the same length

You can tell just from your diagram that the red spokes must be shorter. The blue green could also be different, as your diagram indicates blue has less distance to travel than green.
 
OP
OP
Big John

Big John

Legendary Member
I've seen a few Campag ones like that at work. Campag seem to go for exotic stuff. We've got a Campag hub in the hub drawer with 18 holes on one flange and 9 on the other. On tinterweb I believe they call that 2:1 lacing. Obviously that requires a 27 spoke hole rim. I find bike wheels proper interesting lol. I obviously need to get out more 😉
 

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Photo Winner
Location
Inside my skull
Anyone built wheels like these? If so how do you go about measuring the spoke lengths? I believe it's called paired lacing. The wheel I've got is a bog standard 32 hole hub and the rim I have is just like the ones in the pic, which I've copied off the internet.
View attachment 826880

I am wondering if the rims spoke hole spacing is the same as a 72 hole rim, but with half missing? Thus you are lacing a 2:1 ratio in effect?
 

Ajax Bay

Legendary Member
Location
East Devon
@Big John has a rim drilled for 32 spokes: 8 sets of 4.
The image in the OP is illustrative (as he says) of a similar rim/wheel but with 9 sets of 4 spokes.
His rim has 4 spoke holes per octant (half a quadrant) but all 4 in the first 'half' of the octant and then 3 holes 'missing'. Those four holes have the spacing of a 64 spoke rim.
Apologies for not knowing what a "2:1 lacing ratio" is.
I said upthread, with a 'standard' 32h hub, I thought the spoke length required for this spoking system (see OP for image but 32h) is the same as a normal 32h rim (erd etc). This was simplistic.
I've done some more trig (receipts available) and now calculate that the spokes should be [edit]<deleted>
https://sheldonbrown.com/rinard/spocalc.htm
 
Last edited:

Jameshow

Guru
I've seen a few Campag ones like that at work. Campag seem to go for exotic stuff. We've got a Campag hub in the hub drawer with 18 holes on one flange and 9 on the other. On tinterweb I believe they call that 2:1 lacing. Obviously that requires a 27 spoke hole rim. I find bike wheels proper interesting lol. I obviously need to get out more 😉
Hey BJ, still struggling to grasp what your describing. Any chance of a pic - as they say, paints a thousand words.

The drive side has 18 holes and the non drive side 9 holes to account for the stresses involved in wheel. I don't really think it's a big advantage unless you were chippolini!🤣
 

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Photo Winner
Location
Inside my skull
Apologies for not knowing what a "2:1 lacing ratio"

It’s a 2:1 rim to hub spoke hole ratio. As you calculated, spaced for 64 spoke holes, on a 32 hole hub. As I said, but for 32 not 36 as per photo supplied. Effectively you are lacing a 64 hole rim to 32 hole hub. A recognised pattern for spoke calcs.
 
OP
OP
Big John

Big John

Legendary Member
Hey BJ, still struggling to grasp what your describing. Any chance of a pic - as they say, paints a thousand words.

I put a pic on relating to the original post but if you mean the comment I made about the hub in the drawer with 9 holes on one flange and 18 on the other then i don't have a pic but here's one off the tiinterweb...looks very much like the one we have.

1794924642612.jpeg
 
I have a Campagnolo Ventum wheelset where the rear wheel has 24 spokes: spokes grouped in 3s, one non-drive side (NDS), two drive side (DS) in each set (x 8 obv). The NDS are 2-cross and the DS one is radial. NDS can't be radial because that hub flange has torque to transmit.
I have not investigated but I suspect that this means that the spokes are all the same length and also means the spoke tension is similar (as opposed to 1000N DS and 1500N NDS).
I have had fun constructing this diagram, which is illustrative.
View attachment 826967
Key:
Red - radial NDS
Green - leading
Blue - trailing
I suspect the spoke holes on the flanges are not aligned DS - NDS but offset, to make the three spokes in each set parallel, with equal distance between the NDS and DS spokes (not quite as diagram).

Have you got your DS and NDS swapped round in the emboldened bit?
 

Dogtrousers

Lefty tighty. Get it righty.
Have you got your DS and NDS swapped round in the emboldened bit?

I wondered that too, but as I don't know anything about wheels or wheel building just left it. Intuitively I'd have expected the torque to be coming from the DS flange. But as the hub is rigid maybe it's more complicated than that.

Btw @Ajax Bay I couldn't distinguish between your red and green spokes in the diagram. But I did figure it out using the text. Here endeth today's accessibility lesson.
 
OP
OP
Big John

Big John

Legendary Member
The finished article. A 32 spoke wheel laced 3 cross in a crazy configuration but, strangely, following conventional wheel building rules. Spokes are grouped two leading, two trailing in 8 groups of 4. Begs the question 'Why?'. We're not saving on spoke count, it's a bugger to true and getting a tension meter between the spokes isn't easy.
1000005277.jpg
 
Top Bottom