Exotic wheel lacing pattern.....how to work out the spoke length?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Mr Celine

Discordian
Begs the question 'Why?'
View attachment 827044

It gives a fast running squirrel a fighting chance of running through the wheel without injury. Perhaps.
 

Ajax Bay

Legendary Member
Location
East Devon
It gives a fast running squirrel a fighting chance of running through the wheel without injury. Perhaps.
Well let's examine the chances (and slight apologies for the mixed units).
Let's assume the squirrel is going to run through the wheel at its lowest point: when the two sets of 4 spokes are at 7 o'clock and 5 o'clock.
Halfway (say) 'tween hub and rim offers a gap of width = 60mm: more than enough for a lean squirrel (30mm wide), about 7" off the ground.
The bottom of the wheel - where the tyre touches the ground - is stationary.
At 15mph a 700c wheel rotates about 3 times a second so that 'window' is open (bottom quadrant) for about 1/12th of a second: 0.083s.
Might we reckon a squirrel attempts this 'wheel cross' at 30mph (13.4mps) and with its tail is 500mm long?
'Transit' time is thus 0.075s (squirrel is 30mm 'fat'). Little margin for error. But if the squirrel went for it, I reckon it'd have a 1:64 chance of getting through.
The corollary is that if a squirrel does go for a 'front wheel transit' there a very high chance of unhappiness, for both parties, along the lines of @Jameshow 's recollection.
 
Last edited:

Jameshow

Guru
Well let's examine the chances (and slight apologies for the mixed units).
Let's assume the squirrel is going to run through the wheel at its lowest point: when the two sets of 4 spokes are at 7 o'clock and 5 o'clock.
Halfway (say) 'tween hub and rim offers a gap of width = 60mm: more than enough for a lean squirrel (30mm wide), about 7" off the ground.
The bottom of the wheel - where the tyre touches the ground - is stationary.
At 15mph a 700c wheel rotates about 3 times a second so that 'window' is open (bottom quadrant) for about 1/12th of a second: 0.083s.
Might we reckon a squirrel attempts this 'wheel cross' at 30mph (13.4mps) and with its tail is 500mm long?
'Transit' time is thus 0.075s (squirrel is 30mm 'fat'). Little margin for error. But if the squirrel went for it, I reckon it'd have a 1:64 chance of getting through.
The corollary is that if a squirrel does go for a 'front wheel transit' there a very high chance of unhappiness, for both parties, along the lines of @Jameshow 's recollection.

It's a slow word day today?

Perhaps consider if a 15h hour could go through the spokes to alpine it with the joke thread?!🤣
 
  • Laugh
Reactions: C R

Dogtrousers

Lefty tighty. Get it righty.
Well let's examine the chances (and slight apologies for the mixed units).
Let's assume the squirrel is going to run through the wheel at its lowest point: when the two sets of 4 spokes are at 7 o'clock and 5 o'clock.
Halfway (say) 'tween hub and rim offers a gap of width = 60mm: more than enough for a lean squirrel (30mm wide), about 7" off the ground.
The bottom of the wheel - where the tyre touches the ground - is stationary.
At 15mph a 700c wheel rotates about 3 times a second so that 'window' is open (bottom quadrant) for about 1/12th of a second: 0.083s.
Might we reckon a squirrel attempts this 'wheel cross' at 30mph (13.4mps) and with its tail is 500mm long?
'Transit' time is thus 0.075s (squirrel is 30mm 'fat'). Little margin for error. But if the squirrel went for it, I reckon it'd have a 1:64 chance of getting through.
The corollary is that if a squirrel does go for a 'front wheel transit' there a very high chance of unhappiness, for both parties, along the lines of @Jameshow 's recollection.

This is what I come to CC for
 

Mr Celine

Discordian
Well let's examine the chances (and slight apologies for the mixed units).
Let's assume the squirrel is going to run through the wheel at its lowest point: when the two sets of 4 spokes are at 7 o'clock and 5 o'clock.
Halfway (say) 'tween hub and rim offers a gap of width = 60mm: more than enough for a lean squirrel (30mm wide), about 7" off the ground.
The bottom of the wheel - where the tyre touches the ground - is stationary.
At 15mph a 700c wheel rotates about 3 times a second so that 'window' is open (bottom quadrant) for about 1/12th of a second: 0.083s.
Might we reckon a squirrel attempts this 'wheel cross' at 30mph (13.4mps) and with its tail is 500mm long?
'Transit' time is thus 0.075s (squirrel is 30mm 'fat'). Little margin for error. But if the squirrel went for it, I reckon it'd have a 1:64 chance of getting through.
The corollary is that if a squirrel does go for a 'front wheel transit' there a very high chance of unhappiness, for both parties, along the lines of @Jameshow 's recollection.

I did (briefly) consider trying to work it out myself.
I have had a squirrel appear from the undergrowth in the verge and run between my wheels. We were both physically unscathed but I don't know who got the biggest fright.
 

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Photo Winner
Location
Inside my skull
when the two sets of 4 spokes are at 7 o'clock and 5 o'clock.

If that is the open gap, that is two hours, so a 1/6th of the full 12 hours of a clock face. Does that not mean the window of opportunity is 1/3rd s x 1/6th = 1/18th second? Of course the squirrel is trying to get through at the six o’clock position. Will not the spokes at the five o’clock position get there in 1/18th x 1/2 = 1/36th second?
 
Last edited:
I'm trying to understand where the 0.075s transit time comes from - shouldn't this be 0.5/13.4=0.037s ?

I also find myself wondering whether this is an African or a European squirrel 🤔
 
Last edited:

Ajax Bay

Legendary Member
Location
East Devon
If that is the open gap, that is two hours, so a 1/6th of the full 12 hours of a clock face.
The mid-point of the 4-spoke combo are pointing roughly those o'clocks. But the gap is only an octant.
I'm assuming the nose of the squirrel will hit the gap at speed before its centre is at 6 o'clock.
where the 0.075s transit time comes from - shouldn't this be 0.5/13.4=0.037s ?
Sounds right, in which case the chances are better for the speedy squirrel. Perhaps 15mph is a more reasonable assumption.
Have thrown away the envelope. Try doing all the math and then postulate the probability of a 'clean transit'. Include assumptions.
Bear in mind the squirrel is 30mm wide going through the effective 60mm wide gap.
 

Ajax Bay

Legendary Member
Location
East Devon
"5 o’clock and 8 o’clock" are not the limits for the quadrant's mid point (which is 6 o'clock).
I said: "that 'window' is open (bottom quadrant) for about 1/12th of a second: 0.083s."
I actually envisaged 4:30 and 7:30 (an octant open for a quadrant's 'transit' iyswim) but thought that rather long-winded in text, so I went for 5 and 7 in the expectation that normal people would get the idea: the squirrel has a window of transit opportunity which 'looks' static (not rotating) to him (or her). And limits (left and right spokes) which are (for estimation purposes) moving horizontally.
So pleased 'everyone's' enthused by this real world problem.
Many thanks to @Mr Celine for the initiation of this 'exotic wheel' excursion.
It gives a fast running squirrel a fighting chance of running through the wheel without injury. Perhaps.
 
Top Bottom