I'm assuming Guinness, Caine and Attenborough versions.Not all of these are brilliant, but I'm taking the thread title literally...
The Ladykillers
Brighton Rock
The Italian Job
View attachment 343779
I'm assuming Guinness, Caine and Attenborough versions.Not all of these are brilliant, but I'm taking the thread title literally...
The Ladykillers
Brighton Rock
The Italian Job
View attachment 343779
Better than all those though are classic 1930s/40s Looney Tunes or Tex Avery cartoons.
Oh yes! Back in the mid 90s I had a girlfriend who was a real Looney Tunes aficionado and made me sit through many repeated viewings of her VHS collection. This was not a great hardship. She was really into them for Carl Stalling's superb music as much as anything - she rated him up there with Aaron Copland as one of the great modern American composers.
She was also the one who got me into Groundhog Day. I have a lot to thank her for.
Oh yes! Back in the mid 90s I had a girlfriend who was a real Looney Tunes aficionado and made me sit through many repeated viewings of her VHS collection. This was not a great hardship. She was really into them for Carl Stalling's superb music as much as anything - she rated him up there with Aaron Copland as one of the great modern American composers.
She was also the one who got me into Groundhog Day. I have a lot to thank her for.
We have a couple of Carl Stallings rehearsal/live CD's in the office. Turned up loud they are magnificent. It sounds like you are right in the middle of the orchestral pit. They were tight as a gnats chaff.
A chap called Stu Brown is resurrecting the music and has released a couple of albums called 'Twisted Toons'. He does a great job. Great stuff and Jolly good fun. Well worth checking out.
Yup. Until this moment it had entirely escaped my notice that there was a recent remake of Brighton Rock. How bad is it?I'm assuming Guinness, Caine and Attenborough versions.
Yup. Until this moment it had entirely escaped my notice that there was a recent remake of Brighton Rock. How bad is it?
The Gaslight remake with Bergman and Boyer is pretty good, and I've a soft spot for High Society even though The Philadelphia Story is a better film. Was talking about TTSS last night but I've not seen the film. I reckon avoiding remakes in a general way is likely to save you from more turkeys than it will cost you in missed gems. I wonder what would possess anyone to remake The Ladykillers. And I'm sorry to that I've seen the remake of Get Carter, and what is seen cannot be unseen.Whilst I've not seen said remake it is telling that "how bad is it?" is everybody's instinctive judgement when such a thing is tried. It's nearly always true mind, and an assumption I useally make myself, but there are exceptions:
Tinker Taylor Soldier - to try and remake albeit as a movie rather than TV show, a series containing Alec Guiness at his absolute best is very bold. And to produce something rather fine is a big acheivement.
The recent Solaris remake already mentioned - I thought it superb.
And of course, Fistfull of Dollars is a remake and a classic in it's own right. And Last Man Standing, the remake of the remake isn't bad either
In fact I think it's less interesting than that. Most Hollywood movies are just pretty bad, and a lot of them are remakes of very good movies, so it's just statistically likely that a given remake will be terrible.Interesting. Books regularly get retranslated and the reception, barring that of a few nostalgics, tends to be excited and appreciative; a film is reworked and disappointment is already factored into the expectations and reviews, even after discounting the nostalgics. Maybe we have a deeper personal investment in music and celluloid that we don't want diluted.