It's well known that UK-resident blackbirds are joined in winter by foreign ones. That fits with what we've seen - a couple of residents re-trapped, and loads of big scandinavian-type birds muscling in too.
I guess it might be partly down to our location. We're in a village, but only 50 yards or so from mixed farmland. There are a couple of scrubby patches quite close which I know are sometimes used by a mixture of thrushes and blackbirds as roosts in winter, so it may be that they're simply getting up, coming straight to the garden and waiting there for the food.
A colleague has been ringing mixed thrushes near Ripon and has caught hundreds over the last few days, and new ones are still coming.
People often think they're feeding the same birds for years, and there's usually more individuals than they imagine.
One exception was at the Marine Biology Station at Millport. The kitchen staff there thought they had a regular herring gull coming to be fed; they called him Sammy.
Mrs Uncle Phil and I bodged up a trap from a couple of quadrats and a bungy cord and caught him and ringed him. He didn't enjoy it. There was blood. (Mine. Herring gulls are large, aggressive and powerful). That was in 1999 I think. He's still going there to be fed now - we get updates from time to time.