Is a "fixie" the new mountain bike?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Davidc

Guru
Location
Somerset UK
The word fixie has been around since at least the 1960s, and there was a fashion for them around 1967/68. Loads of them at school.

I tried one but never liked it. What I did have as an n+1 was a singlespeed. Its freewheel was as silent as a fixed wheel, the only cables were for brakes, and being built from a 30 year old 1930s frame, front wheel off a wreck, rear wheel bought for a tanner (6d) from a mate who upgraded to 5 speed gears, and other second hand parts for the rest, it had zero value and meant I could leave the Holdsworth at home when appropriate.

If the current move to fixies, most of which seem to be mis-named singlespeeds or have flip-flops, is a fashion then great. If it gets people onto bikes and keeps them away from things with engines it's good for the rest of us (more bikes around), it's good for the riders (health, their wallets), and the only down side I can think of is more difficulty finding bike parking.

Douglas adams was right that a visitor from another planet would assume the motor car was the dominant life form - roll on the day when instead they'd think humans had 2 wheels and a chain instead of legs!

Edit: When I was young, mad, and endowed with immortality (as are all 16 to 21 year old males) my friends and I always found fixies and singles much easier to deal with than geared bikes when going home from the pub - sober of course - we'd never have ridden under the influence - my nose seems to be getting longer ....
 

400bhp

Guru
The "fixie", "fixed wheel" things sound great - insamuch as they seem to annoy some people. Might have to buy one. :whistle:
 
I'm not to sure what you mean by 'the new mountain bike'. I presume you are referring to the mountain bikes huge uptake by the masses, making cycling popular again and saving the industry? If so then no, I don't think the industry needs saving like it did in the seventies an I don't think fixed wheels have enough appeal to do what the MTB did anyway. MTBs make a lot of sense to a lot of people, even if it's easy to argue that they would be better off with something else. That's not to mention that proper mountain biking is about as much fun as you can have on a bike. Fixies make less sense, I would compare them with something more niche and less useful, BMX for example.
 

tyred

Squire
Location
Ireland
Reasons for riding a derailleur geared bike:

1. Your fixed gear/single speed/hub geared bike is broken and you have nothing else available.
2. You want to ride in seriously hilly terrain and/or carry a very heavy load (and remember that people went loaded touring on fixed/3 speed bikes).
3. Err, cant think of any.
 
The "fixie", "fixed wheel" things sound great - insamuch as they seem to annoy some people. Might have to buy one. :whistle:

Buying one is against the law. You cannot and must not do that.

It goes against nature and it contravenes up to and including fifteen separate elements of nearly twenty different laws.

You must buy an old frame and lie about what you paid for it.

You must then get your LBS to stick the cycleparts on it and claim that you did so yourself.

I must ask you in all seriousness never EVER to speak again of buying a fixie.

I do not think you are a bad person for thinking it was OK to do that... I just think you've been misled by those who haven't seen the light.
 

Jezston

Über Member
Location
London
I bought mine OTS. Charge Plug.

Not the burgundy one with luminous green wheels, right? :wacko:
 

Dan B

Disengaged member
The incessant clicking and skipping and crunching and continually adjusting
gears used to drive me mad :wacko:
I had this problem 20 years ago too, but the indexing technology has come on a bit since then. The incessant hissy-rattly noise from my fixie chain every time I stand up to put some powor down (1/8" chain on 3/32" sprocket probably isn't helping) makes it actually louder than my geared bike, although I have so far resisted letting it drive me any further mad than I already am

The key advantage of fixed gear, I think, is that you can slow down while riding no-handed in traffic without having to grab the handlebars
 

srw

It's a bit more complicated than that...
The key advantage of fixed gear, I think, is that you can slow down while riding no-handed in traffic without having to grab the handlebars

A swerve into a car will let you do the same thing, but I still wouldn't recommend it.
 

srw

It's a bit more complicated than that...
So. Is a fixie the new mountain bike? What have we learned?

Their riders think they're cool.
Their riders have a special terminology which is difficult for outsiders to understand.
Their riders believe their bikes are innately superior to everyone else's bikes.
Their riders think they're a a lot of fun to ride.
Their riders ignore the fact that an awful lot of their good points apply to every bike.
Their riders spend an awful lot of money to get the right look.

Yup, I'd say so. A fixie is exactly like a mountain bike.
 
Top Bottom