1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Overweight and which bike?

Discussion in 'Bikes and Buying Advice - What Bike?' started by Redj, 15 Oct 2017.

  1. Alan O

    Alan O Über Member

    By saying "On grounds of safety alone", I suspect buzzy-beans was thinking of bike skills, traffic, etc.
  2. Regulator

    Regulator Not a SPM snowflake.

    That’s not what the rest of his sentence suggests. Or perhaps he thinks fat people somehow magically lose the ability to ride a bike?
  3. buzzy-beans

    buzzy-beans Well-Known Member

    So you are suggesting that someone riding a bike that has a frame and components that aren't designed to carry their weight goes out onto the open road, let alone them not being fit enough to do this kind of exercise?

    I am sorry but your suggestions are more than somewhat suspect!
  4. Regulator

    Regulator Not a SPM snowflake.

    That’s not what I said, was it? The fact you have to spin and squirm says it all.

    You come across as having an issue with fat people riding bikes in public.
    Last edited: 22 Oct 2017
  5. vickster

    vickster Legendary Member

    @buzzy-beans At what level of being overweight or obesity is it acceptable to cycle on the road? You've expressed the view that the obese shouldn't cycle on the roads in other threads
    Regulator likes this.
  6. Mister Paul

    Mister Paul Legendary Member

    Let's be clear, there have not been quite a few decathlon frame recalls. The two recent ones haven't been linked to rider weight.
    Regulator likes this.
  7. buzzy-beans

    buzzy-beans Well-Known Member

    You couldn't be more wrong, I have issues with road safety and the totally dumb way that some cyclists ride their bikes!

    Categorically I don't have issues with overweight people riding bikes, but I do have issues with people who have little or no experience of riding bikes going straight out onto the oft overcrowded highways before they have any experience.
    I also have distinct issues with people, when considering cycling, who give recommendations to people as in the case in point, with absolutely zilch consideration for their health and safety.................. foolhardy in the extreme is all I will say!
    classic33 likes this.
  8. Mister Paul

    Mister Paul Legendary Member

    So do I. It's pretty risky because of dangerous road users. It shouldn't be.
  9. Regulator

    Regulator Not a SPM snowflake.

    So you think fat people ride bikes in a dumb way? If not, why mention weight in your comments? Let’s just remind our selves of exactly what you said:
    Nothing about road safety - everything about weight.

    Care to point out where anyone has done that on here?

    I’d suggest you stop digging before you make even more of a fool of yourself....
    Last edited: 22 Oct 2017
    growingvegetables likes this.
  10. bozmandb9

    bozmandb9 Insert witty title here

    South Oxfordshire
    BrumJim, Cycleops and Alan O like this.
  11. Spinney

    Spinney Bimbleur extraordinaire Staff Member

    Under the Edge
    Mod note:
    The OP has had some good answers to the original question.
    The thread risks turning into a personal spat between a few posters. Whatever the ins and outs of it, please stop now. Any further posts continuing that argument, from anybody, will be removed. Please stick to bike recommendations.
  12. itaa

    itaa Active Member

    Why not something around £50 and used to start with?

    I ride on a £30 used bike 15-20miles a day ,my gear is a 2x merino wool jumpers from thriftshop for £2 each to keep me warm and fresh , regular clark leather shoes -waxed with stick of £1 wax so they are waterproof, For a windproof Jacket I have a PINK berghaus one I got for free, I'm a guy so wearing PINK isn't my top choice..but does the job. Pump up your tyres really hard and you will get insane boost in speed as well just from that.

    I went From 86kg to 73kg in 2.5 months time just now without spending thousands on a top-notch bike and a silly gear...
    Eat your Greens and Keep it simple!

    Weight loss is made in KITCHEN not with working out!
    xzenonuk, Cycleops and buzzy-beans like this.
  13. buzzy-beans

    buzzy-beans Well-Known Member

    What a truly brilliant and oh so sensible post ^_^:bicycle:^_^, most especially the comment made about the KITCHEN
    Cycleops likes this.
  14. Kernow_T

    Kernow_T Well-Known Member

    Echo the 'respect' of other members' comments and general suggestions are good - and I bow to their better knowledge on anything bike-related.
    Without question you will start losing weight when you start cycling; you don't NEED to pair in with a strict diet, in fact I recommend you don't. Get out on your bike little and often (even if you only have 20-30 mins on a couple of consecutive days) and I bet that will give you the motivation to eat a little better. If you plan for a cycle on Sunday morning, you'll be amazed how much easier it is to eat a healthier option and turn down the whole tub of Ben and Jerry's the evening before!
    Don't force yourself to go without, just wait until you willingly choose to.
    Good luck, you'll be down to 20st in no time
    buzzy-beans likes this.
  15. John Peel

    John Peel Well-Known Member

    Cheshire England

    :smile: I set out on my world tour at 25 stone last August. That's right! I'm the biggest guy ever to attempt to cycle the world, and it hurts like hell :smile:

    Seriously, I had never cycle toured before and not even a regular cyclist, I wear clothes I get from ebay because I can't get cycling clothes without the words Fat Lad at the Back written on them, and my arse hurts daily as the saddle tries its hardest to cut me in half.

    But you know, I have a heavy build and I'm 6ft with shoulders like barn doors. An hod-carrier from leaving school and a hard life in the building industry and a face full of bacon and egg butties, and I am what I am. Well, I am what I am now, which is a couple of stone lighter after just 3300 km's through England, France, Spain, Southern Spain, and now knocking at the gates of Italy.

    I would go for a hybrid style of bike with some bloody strong wheels if I were to just be planning on road cycling. I went for an expedition strength bike due to being off road at times and on crappy roads too. Schwalbe tyres and a good saddle too. I went for a Brooks B17 and it hurt like crazy for the first month, as I was told that it takes the shape of your butt. The ever changing shape of my butt now, means the saddle is almost unrecognisable as a saddle :smile:, but comfy.

    Padded shorts are a must. Trying to get them in 5xl was not easy, so I went for 4xl. Now I look like I'm trying to get a 500g of sausage meat into a 300g skin :smile:, so I wear shorts over them of course.

    Oh, and forget about looking for a light bike, it's hardly going to make a bit of difference to you. Pay £100 more for a bike that weights 2lb less, and lose 2lb easily in your first week of cycling, and that's basically £100 down the drain. And the heavier the bike, the more of a workout you'll get :smile: If you get down to half your current weight, like a racing snake, spending money on a few grams might be worth it, but that's highly unlikely.

    Hope this helps
    Last edited: 7 Mar 2018