Potential Brompton Newbie needs help

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

swansonj

Guru
....
A 29" bottom gear is low. Sufficiently so that if you need lower you'd be as quick walking.
.....
A 29” gear pedalled at 60 rpm is 5mph. If you can walk that fast atall, let alone uphill pushing a bike, I take my hat off to you.
 

TheDoctor

Europe Endless
Moderator
Location
The TerrorVortex
FFS. OK, I can ride at 5 mph. It's difficult to ride at less than that, as it gets hard to balance. So if I needed a lower gear than 29", I'd walk.
Is that better?
 

swansonj

Guru
FFS. OK, I can ride at 5 mph. It's difficult to ride at less than that, as it gets hard to balance. So if I needed a lower gear than 29", I'd walk.
Is that better?
I’m sorry that you clearly found being challenged on what you’d written irritating, but there’s a serious point at issue, and that serious point is that you are giving bad advice, because what works for you is probably not the best solution for the majority of cyclists and (more importantly) potential cyclists.

If you prefer to limit yourself to a 29” bottom gear, and when the hill gets steeper either push harder or get off and walk, then all power to your elbow - everyone should be encouraged to enjoy cycling in whatever way works best for them. But in that spirit, I reckon the majority of the great British public would find hills less offputting if they had lower gears. They usually never get to discover that option, however, because the world of cycling is dominated by sports-derived thinking promulgated by fairly fit and keen cyclists who think that what works best for them should be good for everyone.
 

TheDoctor

Europe Endless
Moderator
Location
The TerrorVortex
Indeed FF is :biggrin:
I'm just replying to the OP asking about standard Brompton builds, rather than custom solutions like compact chainsets. My M12R has a 44-34 chainset, but that's not relevant to the standard / -12% question
 
Top Bottom