Roubaix or Tarmac?

[grellboy]

Morning. I know there is already a thread on here and I have read it, just want a different angle - considering the financial aspects. Currently have a Specialized Allez and a Boardman CX, but work have just started a cycle to work scheme - so now feel obliged to upgrade up to £1000. Anyway, narrowed down two bargains - Specialized Tarmac 2015 - with 105, at £999:00 - or Specialized Roubaix 2014 - only £700 but with Sora only. I know that Roubaix is more comfortable and Tarmac more racy and the Tarmac certainly looks a more sexy in orange, but is it worth the extra £300? On the cycle to work scheme, I imagine the Taiurmac would be c. £660 and the Roubaix £490 ish. Any suggestions?

 

[the snail]

The tarmac is similar geometry to the allez isn't it, so you know what you're getting. If you don't want a more relaxed ride, makes sense to get the tarmac - £170 difference is probably similar cost to upgrading and selling the sora kit.

 

[Elybazza61]

Tarmac easy.

 

[mark st1]

Wouldn't touch Sora with a barge pole worst group set I've ever used. If you don't find the Allez uncomfortable I'd go for the Tarmac. If you want a more relaxed ride go for the Roubaix. Or don't buy a new bike get the new 105 11speed and some new wheels and your bike will feel completely different.

 

[vickster]

Don't think you can use c2w for just parts

Why not look at other brands, often get more bang for buck as compared to specialized

 

[Globalti]

My son and I ride SL4 Roubaix and Tarmac with almost identical wheels, same size, same groupset, same saddle, same tyres. It's difficult to explain the difference but the Tarmac definitely has a lower position and a stiffer feeling frame, which to me feels a little dull, whereas my Roubaix has a more upright endurance positon and a slightly more "lively" springy feel to the frame, which I like very much. However in your position I would go for that Tarmac with 105. Hope that helps.

 

[samsbike]

Whatever frame you like. Personally I would get the roubaix and then change the groupset if that bothered by it as its easier changing that rather than the frame.