I'd be tempted to put it back TBH.
BB30 is very much prone to creaks due to the tight tolerances it has to work with, my own proclivities on the subject are well documented.
I'd replace the spacer, ensure all is clean and greased and rebuild it, I'm sure you'll find it will be OK, for a while at least.
In a nutshell, regular cleaning of BB30 seems to be the way forward.
FWIW I did away with BB30 completely and converted my road bike to Hollowtech II, never had a single issue with it since, but then again BB30 seems to have improved as well in recent months, although it will forever remain the answer to a problem that never existed IMO.
If you still have noise issues it may be worth checking out
THIS site, noises don't always emanate from where you think/expect they might.