SRAM X5 or Shimano Deore?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Plax

Guru
Location
Wales
Okay I've pretty much narrowed down my n+1 list to 2 MTBs (for the time being anyway.....);

Focus Whistler which has 27 speed Shimano Deore gears
Carrerra Kraken with 27 speed SRAM X5 gears.

I've never had SRAM gears before are these better / worse / just the same as Shimano?

Also would you go V-Brake or disc brakes in dusty/sandy/potholed/dry/crap roads? The cost of the Kraken is slightly more (as it hasn't been discounted as much as the Focus which has a higher retail price) but comes with disc brakes but I'm feeling more for the Focus.

Carrera Kraken;


  • Frame Material: Aluminium
  • Frame Size: 17-18
  • Gears: 21+
  • Gender: Mens
  • Suspension: Front
  • Alloy Rims: Yes
  • Brake Type: Hydraulic Disc
  • Chainset: Truvativ Isoflow
  • Fork Lock-out : Yes
  • Fork travel: 120mm
  • Forks: Suntour XCR-D with Remote Lock-Out 30mm stanctions
  • Forks - Adjustable damping : No
  • Frame Colour: Black
  • Frame-: 7005 aluminium frame with double butted main frame tube
  • Front Brake: Tektro Auriga Comp - Wavy Rotors, 180mm
  • Front Mech: Sram X5
  • Gear Shifters: Sram X5 Trigger
  • Handle Bars: Kalloy Oversized - Matt Black
  • Headset: Semi-Intergrated - Black
  • Hubs: Formula DC-20
  • Number of Gears: 27
  • Pedals: Wellgo - alloy platform BMX style
  • Quick Release Wheels: Yes
  • Rear Brake: Tektro Auriga Comp - Wavy Rotors, 160mm
  • Rear Mech: Sram X5
  • Rear Shock: NA (rigid)
  • Rear Shock Adjustable Damping: NA (rigid)
  • Rear Shock Lock-out : NA (rigid)
  • Rims: Strongarm DDM-1, double walled with eyelets
  • Saddle: Carrera
  • Seatpost: Kalloy SP-602 micro-adjust
  • Stem: Kalloy Oversized -Matt Black
  • Tyre size: 2.1
  • Tyres: Continental Speed King
  • Wheel size: 26"
Focus Whistler 2009;
  • Frame Aluminium 6061, zero stack frame
  • Fork Suntour XCT V2-MLO Lockout 80mm
  • Rims Black Comp, double wall, aluminium 19-559
  • Front Hub Shimano Deore, QR
  • Rear Hub Shimano Deore, QR
  • Tyres Schwalbe Smart Sam 54-559 (2.1)
  • Cassette Shimano Deore 9 speed, 11-32T
  • Crankset FSA MTB CK-306, 44/32/22T
  • Bottom Bracket Sealed bearing
  • Shift Levers Shimano Deore, Black
  • Rear Derailleur Shimano Deore, Black
  • Front Derailleur Shimano Deore
  • Chain KMC
  • Brakes Shimano V-Brake
  • Stem Black Comp, Ahead
  • Handlebars Black Comp Flatbar
  • Saddle Concept SL MTB
  • Seat Post Black Comp
 
Top Bottom