The Rail Enthusiast thread

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

mrushton

Senior Member
The original tunnels could be used especially if battery powered traction was employed. The tunnel used for the cables is that built larger to allow for electrification.

It was. The original ones were known as the hell holes. Big enough for a steam engine.must have been horrendous on the footplate. Can't see the politicos getting excited about the project but they should.
 
Last edited:

Jameshow

Guru
Road tunnel would be 14 miles using drill/blast method which is used in eg Norway

Why not boring machines?
 

Andy in Germany

Legendary Member
Well yes unfortunately but rail is expensive and is apparently at capacity

Roads aren't cheap, and the reason for the new link is that they are also at capacity. The difference is that after spending a fortune to build the road, it will essentially be free for the end user whereas rail companies have to cover the cost of the railway. The car lobby gets a great deal there. Even better, they can wait until congestion in east Manchester becomes critical then demand more roads, and the process goes on.

I suspect the people of east Manchester will be less delighted at the prospect of an entirely new dual carriage way emptying on their side of the city

In Freiburg, we have a terminal to load trucks onto trains to transport them through Switzerland to Italy, so they can go through the mountains without clogging up the motorways in Switzerland. The Swiss charge a toll for driving on their motorways, so it isn't more "expensive" to put trucks on the train.
 

mrushton

Senior Member
Roads aren't cheap, and the reason for the new link is that they are also at capacity. The difference is that after spending a fortune to build the road, it will essentially be free for the end user whereas rail companies have to cover the cost of the railway. The car lobby gets a great deal there. Even better, they can wait until congestion in east Manchester becomes critical then demand more roads, and the process goes on.

I suspect the people of east Manchester will be less delighted at the prospect of an entirely new dual carriage way emptying on their side of the city

In Freiburg, we have a terminal to load trucks onto trains to transport them through Switzerland to Italy, so they can go through the mountains without clogging up the motorways in Switzerland. The Swiss charge a toll for driving on their motorways, so it isn't more "expensive" to put trucks on the train.

Sensible thinking from our Euro colleagues. Currently the Lyon-Turin line is being upgraded and some major tunnelling is going on. Line goes through the Maurienne valley so handy for the Telegraphe/Galibier and Madeleine
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turin–Lyon_high-speed_railway
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom